Gerstner Says Poor Parents Do Save but Lack Accounts to Grow Money
He argues cash under a mattress cannot compound, while $5 sent by phone can flow into stocks the next day.

Invest Like the Best with Patrick O'Shaughnessy · Brad Gerstner & Geoffrey Canada - Raising the Floor for Every American Child - [Invest Like the Best, EP.501]Before Brad Gerstner left a New York City tailor shop, the seamstress stopped him with a stock question. She had recognized him from CNBC.
Gerstner, an investor campaigning for investment accounts for every American child, asked if she owned stocks. Mostly, the Jamaican woman told him, she saves cash under her mattress for her children.
Her answer captured the argument he makes about saving in poor families. The problem, as he puts it, is not that poor people do not save. It is that they do not have accounts to save in.
The obstacle is what economists call the cold start problem, he says. Opening a custodial account, an account a parent sets up to hold investments for a child, is so difficult that even a sophisticated person may never finish it.
In his telling, the cost is time. He says that without an account from birth, children miss the first 25 years when small sums could grow as earnings build on earnings, a process investors call compounding.
He compares that idea to the advice attributed to Warren Buffett to start with a small snowball and a very long hill. Starting accounts at birth, he argues, gets everybody past that first hurdle.
Last week in the Bronx, he described a visit to a school of 3,000 students, where his group was adding $250 to each child's account.
The first question from a mother was not when she could spend it. She asked whether she could send $5 or $10 through Apple Pay, the phone payment service.
Gerstner told parents that adding money could be as easy as buying a cup of coffee. He said the deposits are put into the S&P 500, a basket of stocks of large American companies, the next day.
He says saving is very hard for parents today, and the new accounts make it incredibly easy. People care deeply about their children, he says, and they just needed an easy way to join in.
Questions people ask
What does Gerstner mean by the cold start problem?
He uses the phrase to describe his claim that even a sophisticated parent finds it very difficult to open a custodial account for a child. He argues that almost no one will set one up. The child accounts he supports are meant to remove that first step by starting at birth.
What does he mean by missing 25 years of compounding?
Compounding means investment earnings can themselves generate further earnings over time. Gerstner argues that without an early account, children lose the first decades when that process could work. He points to the image attributed to Warren Buffett of starting with a small snowball and a very long hill.
How does Gerstner describe the phone deposit working?
He describes a parent sending $5 or $10 through a phone payment service as easily as buying coffee. He says the money is then automatically placed in the S&P 500 the next day. The Bronx mother's question, in his telling, was whether saving could be that simple.

