KorvaJoin the waitlist
Money

Hanson Says Trump's Prosecutions Made Him Sympathetic and Trapped His Rivals

He says DeSantis and Haley could neither criticize Trump nor defend him without helping him.

AI image
Uncommon Knowledge · The Counter Revolution: Victor Davis Hanson on the Fall and Rise of Trump (Part 1/2)

Republican rivals were trapped either way once prosecutors went after Donald Trump, author Victor Davis Hanson contends: attacking the cases helped Trump, and defending him helped him too.

Interviewer Peter Robinson asked whether Democrats were oblivious to that risk or were deliberately pushing Republicans toward Trump. In Hanson's account, "their hate for Donald Trump clouded their self-interest."

In his telling, political advisers had warned that a heavy legal campaign would turn Trump into a sympathetic figure and block a steadier alternative. That alternative was Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis, whom he describes as a more consistent MAGA figure, less excitable and less prone to offend, fresh off an astounding one-million-vote reelection victory.

The warnings did not stop the cases, because prosecutors believed they would succeed. The prevailing reassurance inside that camp, Hanson says, was, "don't worry, we're gonna put him in jail."

When the Georgia mugshot appeared, along with the other charges, support for Trump rose in the polls rather than collapsing. That surge, in his version, confirmed the miscalculation.

That left DeSantis and former South Carolina Gov. Nikki Haley with no good options in a primary against Trump. Criticizing his conduct risked looking like siding with the prosecution.

Former Attorney General Bill Barr and former Secretary of State Mike Pompeo learned that reaction after suggesting, without harsh language, that Trump could have avoided the documents fight by turning material over. The pushback from Trump supporters was immediate.

Defending Trump was no better. Hanson paraphrases Trump's reply to sympathetic rivals as, come on, support me, followed by a pointed question about why they were running at all.

Either criticism or sympathy ended up strengthening the front-runner, leaving challengers with no room to run. That no-win bind is why Hanson treats the prosecutions as central to Trump's return.

Questions people ask

Who is Ron DeSantis and what happened to his campaign?

DeSantis, the governor of Florida, ran for the 2024 Republican nomination as a culturally conservative and managerial alternative to Trump. He withdrew on January 21, 2024 after a disappointing finish in Iowa and endorsed Trump the same day.

Who is Nikki Haley and how did her campaign end?

Haley, a former South Carolina governor and United Nations ambassador, was Trump's last major Republican rival in 2024. She stayed in the race through Super Tuesday, won Vermont and Washington, D.C., and then suspended her campaign.

More in Money