KorvaJoin the waitlist
Money

Washington Usually Gets About 17 Percent of the Economy

Spending has averaged 21 percent and keeps climbing, while higher rates can push taxpayers to move operations or use deductions.

AI image
Uncommon Knowledge · The Billionaire Tax, The Busted Federal Budget, and the Future of the American Experiment

Raise tax rates, cut tax rates, or rewrite the tax code, and Washington still collects roughly the same share of the economy.

Since 1975, federal revenue has averaged a little more than 17 percent of gross domestic product, the total value of goods and services produced. As of that interview, it was about 17.5 percent, still inside the usual 17 to 18 percent band that has held under very different tax policies.

There was one notable exception. In the late 1990s, during the dot-com boom, revenue rose to almost 20 percent as investors sold booming stocks and paid tax on those capital gains.

The reason for the steadiness, says Joshua Rauh, a Stanford economist, is that taxpayers are human beings. When Congress raises the rate on an activity, people and businesses rearrange their affairs to face less tax.

Some use legal deductions already in the tax code. Others take more damaging steps for the economy, such as moving business operations overseas.

Rauh points to California, which raised taxes sharply in the 2010s, as a smaller version of the same story. Some people left the state, he says, while people who stayed also responded.

That matters because spending has not stayed flat. Federal spending has averaged 21 percent of the economy over the same half century, was 23 percent at the time of the interview, and is projected under current law to reach 24 percent, pushed higher after the financial crisis and the pandemic.

So after tax changes, revenue returns to its 17 to 18 percent range. The gap keeps growing because spending keeps rising, not because revenue keeps falling.

Questions people ask

What does it mean to realize capital gains?

Realization means selling an asset that has risen in value, which creates a taxable capital gain. In the late-1990s stock boom, many investors sold shares at large profits, so the government collected unusually large capital-gains taxes even without raising rates.

Do tax cuts pay for themselves by producing more revenue?

The evidence points to lower rates encouraging more work, investment, and income reporting, which can partly offset the loss from the lower rate. But economists generally find that cuts do not fully pay for themselves, which is why revenue returns toward its long-run share rather than rising above it.

Where does that 17 percent come from?

Federal revenue mainly comes from individual income taxes, payroll taxes for Social Security and Medicare, corporate income taxes, and smaller sources such as excise taxes and customs duties. Individual income and payroll taxes together supply most of the roughly 17 percent of the economy.

More in Money