KorvaJoin the waitlist
Startups

He Raised More Than $100 Million, Then Gave It All Back

He decided the digital collectibles would not last, so no investor lost a dollar.

AI image
David Senra · What It Means to Be a “Real” Entrepreneur | Michael Rubin, Fanatics

The money was already in. Michael Rubin, who leads the sports company Fanatics, had raised more than $100 million from investors for a new business selling NFTs, digital tokens traded as collectibles.

About three months later, he shut it down.

He had decided the product would not last. As Rubin put it, “this is stupid,” and not the kind of product that could support a durable business.

That makes this a rare startup failure with no losers. Rubin returned all the money, so none of his investors lost a dollar.

The move came as NFTs, which had appeared quickly alongside jerseys, hats, trading cards, and video games in the licensed products world, faded just as fast.

For Rubin, the choice was about reputation. He said life is long, and he wants to treat partners fairly and protect relationships that can last for decades.

He had acted the same way after another bad bet. When the apparel brand Mitchell and Ness went “from making a lot of money to losing a lot of money,” Rubin said Fanatics returned partners’ money with a 20 percent return.

Rubin said he is often willing to let sports properties and other partners get the better end of a deal, because Fanatics is “lucky to be in business with them” and he would rather win the long-term partnership than win the negotiation.

Questions people ask

What exactly is an NFT?

An NFT is a digital record, stored on a blockchain, that marks you as the owner of a specific digital item such as art, video, or a collectible. People bought and sold them like trading cards, and prices soared around 2021 before demand collapsed.

How unusual is it to give investors their money back?

Returning money is very unusual. Normally investors in a failed startup lose some or all of their cash, since the money has been spent on staff, marketing, and product. Giving it all back means the founder stopped before those costs consumed the funding.

What does Fanatics do?

Fanatics designs, makes, and sells licensed sports merchandise, runs league and team stores, owns the hat retailer Lids, and has expanded into sports betting and trading cards. Rubin says it now has about $14 billion in revenue and 22,000 employees.

More in Startups