KorvaJoin the waitlist
Relationships

Her Future Abuser, Known as Dirty John, Talked Past Her Noes

Her first night with John Meehan was the start of a relationship in which she later described abuse.

AI image
American History Tellers · LISTEN NOW: The First Wife

After a late shift in surgery in December 1988, Tonia Bales went with four coworkers to a bar called Shooters in Ohio, with George Michael's Faith playing in the background. As she headed for the restroom, a six-foot-two man with brown hair stepped in front of her and started talking.

Bales was 23 and a nurse on the second shift, 3 to 11, at St. Elizabeth's Medical Center in Dayton. Her coworker Terry Hardman, a surgical technician, remembered her as smart, alert, and capable in the operating room.

The man was John Meehan, later known as Dirty John for his coercion and abuse. Bales, his first wife, would spend 10 years with him, have two daughters with him, and later recount abuse and coercion in that marriage.

That first night included moments Bales described as failing to hold her boundary. She agreed to drive him home after saying no, and she agreed to go inside when she had planned to leave.

Meehan was friendly and engaging, and they found common ground in medicine. He said he worked in the cath lab, the hospital unit where staff assist with procedures to diagnose and treat heart problems, at another hospital and was in law school at the University of Dayton.

When he offered to buy her a drink, she ordered a Tom Collins on ladies night, when drinks were free. When the waitress asked for his identification, Bales playfully grabbed his license and saw a birth year that did not match the age 24 he had claimed.

He said he had altered it to buy alcohol in college, and she let it pass. She recalled thinking she knew lots of people who had done that.

Later, when Meehan's ride wanted to leave, he asked Bales to drive him home. She said no, then agreed after he pressed her to stay with him longer. Bales said, "I guess I just didn't know how to be firm in that no." Hardman said she felt uncomfortable and spoke up, only to be told by another friend that she was just jealous.

Bales told herself she would drop him at his house and leave. Instead, he persuaded her to come inside, tossed her a foam basketball mounted over his kitchen doorway, and the play turned to kissing and then to sex. She said it was a first for her in that kind of encounter, and one she still views with embarrassment.

She left the next morning planning never to use the phone number he gave her. But Meehan remembered where she worked, and during her next 3-to-11 shift he had her paged to a phone in the operating room.

Flattered by the attention, she agreed to dinner, then a movie the next night. That was how it started.

Questions people ask

What is the cath lab job Meehan claimed to have?

A cath lab, short for catheterization laboratory, is a specialized area in a hospital where doctors guide thin tubes through blood vessels to look for blockages and treat heart disease. Nurses and technicians there prepare patients, assist during procedures, and monitor them afterward. It was plausible common ground for two hospital workers to discuss.

Why was being paged at work such an effective move?

Before cell phones, hospitals reached staff through overhead pages and calls to room phones. A page into an operating room would interrupt focused, high status work and signal urgency. Calling a new acquaintance that way showed persistence, knowledge of her routine, and confidence.

What is a Tom Collins?

It is a tall mixed drink made with gin, lemon juice, sugar, and carbonated water, served over ice. In the 1980s it was a common, uncomplicated bar order. Bales said the free ladies night drinks were "not too much of a burden" on him.

More in Relationships