KorvaJoin the waitlist
Relationships

She Caught His Lie About His Age and Let It Go

He said he had altered his license to buy alcohol in college, and she gave it no further thought.

AI image
American Scandal · LISTEN NOW: The First Wife

George Michael's Faith was playing at a Dayton bar called Shooters when John Meehan stepped in front of Tanya Bales as she headed to the bathroom.

Meehan would later become her husband, the man at the center of the Dirty John case.

Bales was 23 and worked as a nurse in surgery in Dayton, Ohio. She was out after a late shift with about five coworkers who were close to her in age.

She stopped for a brief chat, then found Meehan waiting to talk again when she came back. He was engaging, friendly, and full of questions, starting with where she worked.

That small moment mattered because Bales caught Meehan saying he was 24 when his license showed a different birth year, and she let it pass.

Meehan said he knew another nurse from her hospital, said he worked with heart patients at another hospital, and said he attended law school at the University of Dayton.

When he offered to buy her a drink, she ordered a Tom Collins on a night when women's drinks were free. The waitress asked him for identification, and Bales playfully grabbed it to check the birth year.

The year did not match the age of 24 he had just claimed. He answered that he had changed the license to buy alcohol in college.

Tanya Bales said she knew many people who had done that. She said of his answer, "I really didn't think another thing about it."

Later, when Meehan's ride wanted to leave, he asked Bales to drive him home. She first refused, then agreed though she did not want to, and at his house she had planned only to drop him off.

Instead, he persuaded her to go inside. She left planning never to call him, but the next night he used the workplace she had named to have her paged during surgery and ask for a dinner date, and she agreed to dinner and then a movie.

Questions people ask

What is a Tom Collins?

A Tom Collins is a tall cocktail made with gin, lemon juice, sugar, and fizzy water, served over ice. On ladies' night in the 1980s, bars often gave women free or cheap drinks to draw a crowd.

What is a cath lab?

A cath lab is a hospital unit where doctors thread thin tubes through blood vessels to diagnose and treat heart problems. Nurses and technicians assist there, so his claim gave him an easy professional connection to a surgical nurse.

Was altering a license to buy alcohol a common excuse at the time?

Yes, especially around colleges in the 1980s, when many states were raising the drinking age to 21. Young people often changed the birth year on a license, so his story would have sounded familiar rather than alarming.

More in Relationships