KorvaJoin the waitlist
Startups

Most Jobs Don't Vanish, They Move Up

Venture investor Claire argues AI shifts work to more useful tasks, from wake-up knockers to logo-moving analysts.

AI image
youtube.com · https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ht_DuxWLh8M

Claire, a venture investor who explains tech in short online videos, was giving her view on worries that artificial intelligence will wipe out junior jobs on Wall Street and elsewhere. The discussion offered no data on whether those jobs are actually shrinking.

Her answer started wider. She said it is “very easy to overestimate the short-term impact of technologies” and very difficult to remember the long-term potential.

Most of the time, she argued, work moves to a higher, “more useful level.”

A century ago, she noted, getting information, including financial information, meant visiting a library.

Before the invention of the alarm clock, she said, some people earned a living by waking early and going house to house to rouse sleepers. That person 150 years later, she argued, “is probably doing something a lot more fulfilling and interesting than being a human alarm clock.”

She applied the same logic to early computing, when women plugged wires in and out by hand to process calculations.

She had made a video about finance tools built on AI and the fear that AI will take analysts’ jobs. When analysts stayed up until 2 a.m. moving logos around and manually typing notes, she asked, “Was that a fulfilling task for them?”

She said the more fulfilling task “is learning the judgment and storytelling around how to pitch or how to tell a story around an IPO” (a company’s first sale of stock to the public). That logo work, she said, is work “which AI can do now at 2 a.m.”

She allowed one limit. For certain roles like coding and contact center work, meaning customer service call centers, she said machines can directly swap in for people. But for most jobs, she argued, there is “a little bit of a tunnel vision when it comes to this labor story.”

Questions people ask

Were there really human alarm clocks?

They were called knocker-uppers in industrial Britain, and they used sticks, rattles, or peashooters to tap on bedroom windows until factory workers woke. The job faded as cheap mechanical alarm clocks spread in the early 1900s.

Who were the women who did computing by hand?

They were people, often women, whose job title was literally computer, and who performed calculations by hand or by physically configuring early machines. Their work underpinned astronomy, military ballistics, and early electronic computing.

Are Wall Street analyst jobs actually changing this way?

Banks still hire large analyst classes, but software now drafts slides, cleans data, and summarizes filings that analysts once prepared manually. The remaining premium is on client judgment, deal storytelling, and spotting errors, which matches the shift described in the story.

More in Startups