KorvaJoin the waitlist
Startups

Leaders' Big Bets May Rest on Untested Beliefs

Research on moves like hiring a star from a rival suggests they may not pay off.

AI image
library.hbs.edu · Four Ways to Build a Culture of Scientific Experimentation | Working Knowledge

In his new book, The Scientific Mindset, author Stefan H. Thomke describes a familiar corner office decision. A chief executive tries to rescue a business unit by bringing in a top performer from a rival.

The logic feels like common sense: a better leader should mean better financial results. Thomke argues the thinking rests on beliefs about what causes what that rarely get checked.

Leaders make such bets every day about products, customers, and where to put money and people. They matter most when they lock a company into moves that are hard to undo.

In the star hire example, research has shown the move may not improve results. Thomke's warning is that beliefs like that have "rarely, if ever, been critically examined."

The same problem shows up in the way managers defend old habits. When asked why they did not question a practice that later proved flawed, people often answer, “I’ve always been successful doing it this way.”

Past failure can harden thinking in the other direction. People insist, “this idea will never work,” because a previous attempt embarrassed or frustrated them.

Scientific thinking starts with accepting that people misjudge situations and grow comfortable with shaky beliefs. Its value becomes clear when tests reveal those beliefs are wrong or out of date, giving leaders reason to replace hunch with evidence.

Questions people ask

Why would a star performer struggle after changing companies?

Often performance depends on context, not just talent. Knowledge of customers, trusted colleagues, internal systems, and reputation inside one company do not move with a person. A star can also struggle if the new role, team, or strategy demands different skills.

What does thinking scientifically look like for a busy manager?

It means turning a belief into a testable prediction, then comparing what happens with and without the change. A manager might try a new price, message, or process with one group of customers while keeping the old version for a similar group. Decisions then follow the evidence rather than seniority or habit.

More in Startups