Killing A King Left The Monarchy Intact
The Italian anarchist Errico Malatesta said revenge was futile after King Umberto I was shot in 1900.

Behind the Bastards · It Could Happen Here Weekly 258After Gaetano Bresci, an Italian silk weaver turned anarchist organizer, shot King Umberto I of Italy in 1900, fellow anarchist Errico Malatesta wrote an answer to what Bresci had done.
Bresci had been enraged by an event two years earlier. In 1898, soldiers commanded by General Fiorenzo Bava Beccaris killed at least 118 demonstrators in Milan during unrest over food prices, and wounded hundreds more. King Umberto praised the crackdown and gave the general Italy's highest decoration, and Bresci later testified that this convinced him the king deserved to die.
More than a century later, a similar logic appeared when Luigi Mangione, a former technology worker, selected Brian Thompson, the chief executive of UnitedHealthcare, as an embodiment of the American health insurance system. But in both cases, the office survived the man. Umberto was replaced by Victor Emmanuel III, and Thompson was replaced by another executive.
The systems stayed intact in other ways too. After Umberto's death, the Italian state continued and used anarchist violence as justification for more surveillance and repression. After Thompson's death, private health insurance kept the same structure and business model, and the clearest corporate response was more spending on executive security.
Malatesta, who rejected assassination as a tactic, argued that revenge missed the point. He wrote that lone attacks carried out before the public is organized to support change achieve nothing and bring harsh retaliation, adding, "The essential, incontrovertible, purposeful act lies not in the physical killing of a king, but in killing all kings."
By that, he said, he meant ending belief in authority in courts, parliaments, factories, and minds, and building the moral and material strength needed to bring down a violent system with as little violence as possible. He added, "We do not mean to be either executioners or avengers."
Questions people ask
What happened to Bresci after the assassination?
Bresci was seized by the crowd after shooting Umberto at a public event in Monza on July 29, 1900. He was later held in isolation on the island prison of Santo Stefano and died in May 1901, which authorities called suicide.
Who was Errico Malatesta?
Malatesta was a prominent Italian anarchist writer and organizer who had been active for decades by 1900. Bresci had once disarmed a man who tried to stab him, though the two were not described as close friends.
What was the legal outcome for Mangione described in the source?
Mangione faced a federal murder charge carrying a possible death penalty, which was later dismissed, and he pleaded guilty to two federal stalking charges resulting in death. A separate New York case remained unresolved amid a dispute over double jeopardy.


