Medicare for All Is Popular Until Private Insurance Disappears
Ezra Klein argues that making hidden health costs visible as taxes may have helped sink Vermont's single payer try.

The Ezra Klein Show · Hasan Piker Wants to WinStreamer and political activist Hasan Piker says Medicare for All has its highest support ever, at 66 percent, "according to the Kaiser Family Foundation." He hedges that number with "I believe," presenting it as his recollection of the polling.
Journalist Ezra Klein says one problem when a single-payer plan absorbs the whole system is the way American health care hides its price. Most workers outside Medicare and Medicaid have much of their premium paid by an employer, so they never see the full cost, and parts of the spending are buried in tax breaks.
Klein links Vermont's single payer failure in part to those hidden costs becoming visible. Vermont had full Democratic trifecta control and the effort fell apart for different reasons.
In theory, Klein says, putting everything into one government plan turns what employers pay and what is hidden in tax deductions into an explicit tax. The total national bill might be lower, he says, but to voters the new tax looks larger than what they thought they were paying before.
On trust, Klein points to a joint survey by a progressive group and the centrist firm Searchlight, pairing a left and a centrist pollster. In that poll, people said they wanted Medicare for All, but said no when asked if they wanted private insurance taken away, and no when asked if they trusted government more than their insurer.
Piker says people love their doctors but despise "Aetna and Blue Cross Blue Shield." Klein says "the costs are coming from the providers first and foremost," and that insurers pass those costs along rather than fighting providers. He says lasting savings would require price controls on doctors and hospitals, who would fight cuts to their pay.
Piker said, "I don't think that biting it all at once is something that is feasible or possible right now," but he still wants Medicare for All as a legislative North Star. Klein favors an incremental trust building path, citing another guest, Abdul El-Sayed, who compared the climb to Mount Everest, reached in stages from base camp.
Questions people ask
Would I get to keep my own doctor under Medicare for All?
No plan guarantees it, and that fear helps explain the polling. People often dislike their insurer but like their doctor, so any proposal has to convince them they can keep that relationship.
How do other countries with single-payer systems pay for health care?
Largely through broad taxes that everyone can see, such as income or payroll taxes. Because the tax is visible from the start, voters there do not experience the shock of having hidden employer payments suddenly relabeled as taxes.
Why do employers pay for health insurance in the first place?
It grew out of World War II wage controls, when companies barred from raising pay competed by offering health benefits. The tax code later favored those benefits, and employer coverage became the normal arrangement for working-age Americans.


