KorvaJoin the waitlist
Food

Pick the Steak You Like, Ask for Even Cuts, and Match the Wine to It

Ask the butcher for steaks of equal thickness, and match the wine to how rich the meat is.

AI image
thefloridavillager.com · Planning an Epic Steakhouse Dinner Party at Home - The Florida Villager - Your Community Lifestyle Magazine

Emily Joswiak, who wrote a guide to hosting a steakhouse dinner at home, says a good talk with the butcher makes shopping easier and cooking more predictable. Choose steaks you enjoy and can cook well.

Ribeye is the rich one, thanks to streaks of fat through the meat. Filet is the softest bite but tastes milder, while New York strip lands in the middle with a pleasing texture and bold taste.

Let guests' preferences and your confidence decide. You do not need six different cuts to impress, and one different steak for one guest is enough. Thick steaks give more room to brown the outside without overcooking the center.

At the counter, explain how many people are coming and whether you will grill or use the stove. Ask for steaks cut to one shared thickness so timing stays even. Go over portion size in light of appetites and side dishes.

If a premium upgrade tempts you, ask the butcher to explain the differences between the choices. Joswiak says a well-marbled choice might fit your budget better than the priciest cut in the case.

Then match the bottle to richness, not the label. She steers fatty ribeye toward a full Cabernet Sauvignon, and lean filet toward a gentler Merlot or Pinot Noir. Seasoning and sauce can shift the call, so factor those in.

Offer a festive nonalcoholic drink, too, such as sparkling water with citrus. Start with the cut your group will like, and build the wine around it.

Questions people ask

How thick should I ask the butcher to cut the steaks?

For a steakhouse style dinner, about 1 to 1.5 inches thick is a practical target for most home cooks. That thickness gives time to brown the outside while keeping the center juicy. Thinner steaks can go from rare to well done very quickly.

What if guests want different levels of doneness?

Even thickness helps, but different cuts and requested doneness levels will still finish at different times. Put thicker or more marbled steaks on first when needed, and use an instant-read thermometer to check each steak. Letting steaks rest a few minutes also gives you time to finish the rest.

Should I chill Cabernet Sauvignon or Pinot Noir before serving?

Serve most reds slightly cool, around 60 to 65 degrees, rather than warm room temperature. If the bottle feels warm to the hand, chill it for 15 to 20 minutes. A large glass and a small pour leave room for aroma and refills.

More in Food