KorvaJoin the waitlist
Money

Random Startup Portfolios Perform About as Well as Real Venture Funds

Even blind picks produce the same boom-or-bust pattern, but what you pay still matters.

AI image
This Week in Startups · NVIDIA Ousts Jensen, AI Comes for Nerds & Walmart Is A Bubble?!

Pick startups at random and you would end up with results that look strikingly like those of professional venture capitalists.

That is the finding of a finance study published in May, described by D.A. Wallach, who helps lead Time BioVentures. One author, J.P. Bouchaud, runs one of Europe's largest quant hedge funds. His team built random portfolios that held the same number of companies as real venture portfolios.

To keep the test fair, the researchers matched the random picks to the real ones by valuation, sector and investment size. They then compared cash-on-cash multiples, meaning how many dollars came back for each dollar put in. The spread of outcomes for random portfolios almost perfectly overlapped the spread for real portfolios.

Behind both sets of results is what investors call a power law, Wallach said, in which a few companies produce huge gains and most return little or nothing. That pattern showed up whether humans chose or the selection was random. In a given year, the best random portfolio performed roughly as well as the best real fund.

Tim Draper of Draper Associates questioned how the method would work in practice. He said, “I get 80,000 opportunities a year and I do about 100 of them.”

Separately, Wallach agreed the study covers only companies that raised a round, leaving out startups that never raise money.

That matching on valuation was meant to keep the comparison fair. As a separate finding in the paper, Wallach said, entry price matters, and more reasonably priced deals did better.

Wallach offered a counterpoint to the idea that picking makes no difference. He argued that the best-performing managers show persistence year to year, which would not happen if results were purely random. That persistence, he said, may reflect access to the best deals as well as skill in picking them.

Questions people ask

What is a power law in startup investing?

A power law means a few extreme outliers dominate the average. In startups, one company in a portfolio may return 50 or 100 times the investment while most return little or nothing. That one winner can make the whole fund successful.

What does cash-on-cash multiple mean?

It is total cash returned divided by total cash invested. A 3x cash-on-cash multiple means $1 million invested returned $3 million. Venture investors use it to compare funds without adjusting for timing.

Does this prove venture capitalists add no value?

No. The study compares company selection after startups have already cleared the hurdle of raising money. It does not measure help with hiring, customers, follow-on funding, or company building. It also does not capture getting access to the most sought-after deals in the first place.

More in Money