KorvaJoin the waitlist
Tech

Harris Said in 2017 That Control Rooms Would Shape What a Billion People Think

Former Google design ethicist Tristan Harris said in 2017 that phone notifications schedule thoughts you maybe did not intend to have.

AI image
TED · How a handful of tech companies control billions of minds every day | Tristan Harris

In a 2017 talk, Tristan Harris, a former design ethicist at Google, asked his audience to picture something strange. Imagine walking into a control room, he said, with a hundred people hunched over desks with little dials.

That room, he said, "will shape the thoughts and feelings of a billion people." "This might sound like science fiction, but this actually exists right now, today," he added, meaning in 2017.

He said he knew because he had worked in one. At Google, he studied how to ethically steer people's thoughts.

Harris said what people do not talk about is "how the handful of people working at a handful of technology companies through their choices will steer what a billion people are thinking today," meaning that day in 2017.

He made it concrete with the phone in your pocket. When designers decide how it works or what goes on the feed, he said, they are "scheduling little blocks of time in our minds."

Harris said, "If you see a notification, it schedules you to have thoughts that maybe you didn't intend to have." Tapping it, he argued, can turn into time spent on something you had not meant to pursue.

The reason, he argued, is a hidden goal steering all technology. It is the race for attention, because every news site, election, politician, game, and even meditation app has to compete for it, and there is only so much of it.

The best way to win, he said, is to know how the mind works. He said he had learned such persuasive techniques as a student at the Persuasive Technology Lab.

YouTube was his simple example from 2017. To maximize viewing time, it autoplays the next video. For Harris, that one design choice showed how a small room of designers could decide how very many people spend their time.

Questions people ask

Why does Harris call attention a race?

Harris argues technology is not evolving randomly but in one direction, because every news site, politician, game, and even meditation app must compete for attention. Since attention is limited, he says, the designs that win are the ones best at capturing it.

What does he mean by scheduling time in our minds?

He means that design choices decide what you think about next. A notification can plant a thought you maybe did not plan to have, and swiping on it can turn into time spent on something you maybe did not plan to follow. In his telling, those small prompts add up to steering time and thought.

More in Tech