KorvaJoin the waitlist
Money

The Safest Debt Failed Worst, and the Riskiest Paid Best

Milken says the labels promised safety, but extra interest covered extra defaults.

AI image
In Good Company with Nicolai Tangen · Mike Milken: Access to Capital, the American Dream, and Why Risk Is Misunderstood

Investors have long sorted debt by its label, and Mike Milken, the financier known for turning junk bonds into a major market, argues they sorted it backward. He says the debt called safest failed worst, while the debt called too risky paid best.

The convention was simple. Debt rated investment grade was treated as careful and sound, and debt below that line, owed by most companies in the world, was treated as speculation to avoid.

In Milken's account of research on the worldwide Depression of the 1930s, the lower the quality of the debt investors bought, the higher the return, even after adjusting for risk. He says the reason was that risk premiums, the extra interest demanded for riskier loans, were too large.

In the 1930s, Milken says, banks were not even required to set aside reserves against sovereign debt, or loans to national governments, since it was treated as free of risk, and he says most countries carried triple-A ratings regardless of the facts.

Milken points to Venezuela, rated triple-A at a time of 30 percent unemployment, as an example of how little the label measured.

He says the same inversion appeared from 2007 to 2010. The biggest losses were not in below-investment-grade debt, but in debt rated investment grade, especially bonds backed by real estate and stamped AAA, AA, or A.

His point, he says, is that every kind of investment carries risk. He asks whether investors are building in a reserve for expected credit losses.

Questions people ask

What does triple-A actually mean?

Triple-A is the top grade from a credit rating agency, meant to signal a very low chance of default. Agencies also use AA, A, BBB, and grades below BBB that are often called speculative or high yield. The grades are opinions, not guarantees, and they can be wrong.

What is a risk premium?

It is the extra interest investors demand for taking extra risk. If a safe government bond pays 4 percent and a riskier company bond pays 8 percent, the 4 point difference is the risk premium. If defaults cost less than that premium over time, the riskier bond wins.

What does it mean to build in a reserve for credit risk?

It means assuming some loans will fail and pricing or reserving for that in advance. A bank might set aside part of earnings against future defaults, or an investor might demand a higher yield. Milken’s point is that even highly rated debt needs that cushion.

More in Money