KorvaJoin the waitlist
History

Two Officers Plotted to Oust Their Commander, and a Sergeant Said No

Without support from the enlisted men, the plot collapsed, and Greely soon admitted his mistakes and asked his officers for help.

AI image
American History Tellers · Greely Arctic Expedition | The Longest Winter | 3

On the night of August 15, 1883, Sergeant David Brainerd lay in his sleeping bag in a wooden whaling boat and tried to sleep. The sea ice creaked and moaned around him, and two men whispered nearby beside the shore of Ellesmere Island in the far north.

One voice called him over. It was Dr. Octave Pavie, the doctor for Commander Adolphus Greely's American Arctic expedition, sitting with Lieutenant Frederick Kislingberry in another boat.

They were about to ask Brainerd, who led the enlisted men, to join a mutiny. Just six days after leaving their base at Fort Conger, the choice would decide who commanded the expedition and whether it stayed together.

Greely had proposed abandoning the expedition steamship, the Lady Greely, hauling the smaller boats onto a large floating sheet of ice, and riding it south to Cape Sabine. Brainerd privately called the idea madness in his diary, and many of the men questioned Greely's judgment and feared his choices could get them killed.

Pavie told Brainerd the floe plan was downright insane and might even make Greely unfit to command. He cited other erratic behavior, including threatening to shoot another sergeant, and said he would declare Greely insane so Kislingberry could take over and lead the party back to Fort Conger to wait through the winter.

Brainerd hesitated. He liked the idea of returning to shelter, but he prided himself on being a good and obedient soldier. Pavie grabbed his jacket collar and told him the fate of the plan rested on him.

Brainerd refused. “I won't be involved in any mutiny, and I don't want to hear any more of this treasonous talk,” he said. He added that he would resist such actions with his life, then climbed out of the boat into the wind.

Without Brainerd, Pavie and Kislingberry dropped the attempt. They stayed resentful and mistrustful, but knew they could not remove Greely without the enlisted men behind them.

Greely, for his part, soon dropped the floe plan as too dangerous and pushed south by boat, passing the halfway point to Cape Sabine on August 22. After progress later stalled, he admitted that commanding on water was unfamiliar work for him and that he had made questionable decisions, invited his officers to offer plans, and morale improved. On September 9, the officers jointly decided to abandon the steam launch, whose engine was failing and whose fuel was short.

Questions people ask

Why did going back to Fort Conger sound safer than going forward?

Fort Conger was the expedition's built base, with buildings, shelter, and supplies left behind. Returning meant going back to a known place to wait through the winter, while pushing south meant traveling toward an uncertain meeting point with little food or shelter ahead.

Why was Kislingberry already out of favor before the mutiny plot?

The account says Kislingberry had resigned his post two years earlier and had been stripped of command. That is why Greely later held an officers meeting that included Brainerd and Pavie but excluded Kislingberry.

Did Brainerd stay with Greely after refusing the plot?

Brainerd remained a central figure in the party through the worst of the ordeal. Months later, when the starving survivors thought they heard a rescue ship, it was Brainerd who went out with Private Francis Long to look.

More in History