KorvaJoin the waitlist
Startups

VCs Care More About Upsells Beating Churn Than About Product-Market Fit

Even satisfied users may not expand, so growth must outweigh cancellations and cutbacks.

AI image
A Product Market Fit Show | Startup Podcast for Founders · Forget PMF—Neil Patel says to give your product away for free instead. | Neil Patel, Co-Founder of Neil Patel Digital

Neil Patel, a longtime startup founder who now runs NP Digital, a global ad agency, was explaining how venture capitalists pick winners. He said most investors do not try to fix churn, the revenue lost when customers cancel or pay less.

"What they really care for is you have churn, but your upsells make up for the churn plus more," Patel said.

By upsells, he meant extra revenue from existing customers who upgrade, add seats, or buy more. When that expansion outweighs cancellations and cutbacks, investors describe the result as net negative churn, also called net dollar retention.

Patel said most venture capitalists look for companies that already have low churn, then focus on how much money is needed to scale. He argued that product-market fit does not guarantee that result.

Patel pointed to the well known test linked to startup adviser Sean Ellis. The Ellis test sets the benchmark at 40 percent of users saying they would be very disappointed without the product.

Customers can be happy, even saying they would be very disappointed to lose the product, without spending more. When other customers cancel or pay less at the same time, overall retention still falls below 100 percent.

That math matters most when the checks get large, Patel said. By big money, he meant software rounds of 20, 30, 50, or 100 million dollars, where investors want to see upsells bring in more than cancellations and cutbacks take away.

He called that a very hard thing to achieve, and said industry helps explain why. Marketing software tends to have terrible churn, he said, while security software has much less churn built in. Selling into a growing industry helps because surviving customers grow and expand, as with online stores where bigger stores make up for smaller ones that close.

Questions people ask

What is the difference between contraction and cancellation?

Contraction means existing customers stay but pay less, through downgrades, fewer seats, or discounts. Cancellation means they leave entirely. Patel groups both as losses that upsells must outweigh.

Why would industry change churn so much?

The reason given is that a growing customer base creates a tailwind for expansion. If retained customers grow, they add seats and spend more, which helps upsells outweigh losses. The example given is online stores, where bigger stores make up for smaller ones that close.

Why does this math matter more for large checks?

Patel ties large checks to proof of net dollar retention and growth. For checks of 20, 30, 50, or 100 million dollars, he says investors want to see upsells bring in more than contraction and cancellations take away.

More in Startups