Why AI Startups Gain Little by Buying Older Software Firms
The buyer gets the contracts along with the headaches, with little thanks for fixing them.

The Twenty Minute VC (20VC): Venture Capital | Startup Funding | The Pitch · 20VC: Jensen Huang Investigation: What Happens Now | Sequoia Leave London, Close Scout Program and End Evergreen Fund | NASDAQ Loses $2.5TRN in 24 hours | Anthropic targets $1.4TRN IPO valuationOn paper, it looks like a shortcut. An AI startup that needs customers could simply buy an older software company, take over its contracts, and upgrade everyone to something smarter.
Investor Jason Lemkin raised the obvious question: why don't AI companies just buy the older firms for their contracts and customers?
Lemkin said the answer is pace. The AI native companies are growing too quickly for such a deal to matter, and both sides have to be “growing within a band” for a purchase to be worth it. He called such deals “never worth doing.”
The reason is what comes with those agreements. A buyer takes over prior commitments along with all the difficulties attached to them.
Investor Rory O’Driscoll put it this way: “you buy someone else's old contracts and then you incurred all their problems and the customer is never grateful for you for solving it.” For these older customers, he put the choice bluntly as “march or die.”
Questions people ask
When does buying another software company for customers ever make sense?
It can, when the products fit closely and growth rates are similar. The buyer can then add customers without taking on a very different technology or a long list of service obligations. When a fast grower buys a slow grower, the added revenue is small relative to the work.
What does it mean for an older software company to become AI native?
It means rebuilding the product around AI, changing how work gets done, and often using fewer people. In software, that can mean automated support, AI-written code, and tools that do tasks themselves rather than requiring users to click through screens.
If customers are unhappy, why do they become the buyer’s problem after an acquisition?
Contracts usually transfer with the company, so the buyer takes on the promises to keep the software running. Customers may still leave at renewal, but until then the complaints and repair work belong to the new owner.


