KorvaJoin the waitlist
Psychology

Waiting a Month to Conceive Creates a Different Child

Two mothers make the same selfish choice with very different moral math, and philosophers still struggle to explain why.

AI image
Modern Wisdom · Why Atheists Keep Finding God (in everything) - Alex O’Connor - #1175

Imagine two women who each have a child born without functioning legs, after refusing an easy way to prevent it. Our instinct is that both did something wrong, but philosophy suggests only one harmed her child.

In the first case, described by Alex O'Connor, who speaks and writes about philosophy and religion, a woman is already pregnant. A simple pill would allow the fetus to develop healthy legs. She refuses because she wants the sympathy that comes with a disabled child.

That refusal clearly harms someone. The same child would have existed with healthy legs, and because of her choice will live without them.

In the second case, a woman is not yet pregnant but has a temporary condition. If she conceives now, the child will be born without functioning legs. If she waits a month until the condition passes, she will have a healthy child.

She also refuses to wait, for the same selfish reason, and also has a disabled child. She seems just as guilty. Yet the child she has owes his existence to her timing.

Had she waited, a different egg and sperm would almost certainly have met, producing a different person. That disabled child cannot sensibly say, I wish you had waited, because waiting would have meant he was never born at all, so long as his life is worth living.

That is the puzzle identified by Oxford philosopher Derek Parfit, called the non-identity problem. We usually define harm as making someone worse off than he otherwise would have been, but here no one is worse off.

The healthy child who might have been born was never a real person, and we do not harm possible people by failing to create them. So O'Connor asks, if no one was harmed, what exactly made the second choice wrong.

The answer matters for decisions made before conception, such as choosing among embryos. If selecting a disadvantaged child in advance harms no particular person, it becomes strangely difficult to explain why it is wrong, even while editing the genes of an existing embryo clearly is.

Questions people ask

Does conceiving a month later really create a different child?

Yes, in most cases. A child conceived a month later would come from a different egg, and usually different sperm as well. That combination carries different genes, so it would develop into a different person, not the same person with better health.

Why does the child who was never born not count as harmed?

Philosophers generally say we have duties to people who exist or will exist, not to merely possible people. There are countless children you could create but do not, and treating each failure to conceive as harm would make ordinary life impossible.

What is a wrongful birth lawsuit?

They are rare lawsuits in which parents, and sometimes a child through parents, claim that medical negligence deprived them of the chance to prevent a birth involving severe disability. Courts treat them very differently by place, and many jurisdictions do not allow a child to sue for having been born.

More in Psychology