KorvaJoin the waitlist
Startups

When a Trusted Subordinate Says No, Assume They See Something You Don't

State the real objective, like gaining high ground and visibility, and let the team find another way to reach it.

AI image
Not Dead Yet · Leif Babin

Leif Babin, a former Navy SEAL platoon commander who served in Ramadi, Iraq, in 2006, has a rule for what to do when a trusted subordinate says no.

Picture this. You order a fire team leader, in charge of four or five men, to take a building. Call it building 120. He answers, negative.

Do not pull rank. Babin said the refusal tells him the subordinate knows something he does not. A boss cannot be everywhere.

He may be looking under a gate and seeing wires that suggest a buried roadside bomb, known as an improvised explosive device. If he walks through that gate, he could lose several men.

So pause and share the thinking behind the order. To explain, Babin pictured building 120 as a four story apartment building with concrete walls.

From the roof, his men could gain high ground, see for blocks in every direction, and understand what was happening around them. That visibility was the real objective, not that one address.

Then restate the task as broad guidance and let him solve it. Ask, can you get your men up high somewhere so we can see what is going on. Good leaders give broad guidance and let people execute.

He can pick another building, another route, or another position that gives the same advantage without crossing the wires you could not see.

Questions people ask

What is decentralized command?

It is a leadership term for telling people the purpose, the desired end state, and the limits of their authority, then letting them decide how to execute. In combat, the senior officer cannot be everywhere, so junior leaders must solve problems, move around obstacles, or recommend changes up the chain.

Does the boss just accept whatever the subordinate proposes?

No. Babin said his senior, Jocko Willink, did not blindly accept a plan. He asked questions and tweaked it based on things Babin did not know, like another operation or available aircraft and drone support. Babin said a subordinate should generally execute the boss's plan, because pushing back every time makes the boss dismiss him as argumentative and costs him influence.

What exactly is an IED?

An improvised explosive device is a homemade bomb, often buried by a road or gate and triggered remotely or by pressure. In Iraq, insurgents hid them in streets, doorways, and debris, so wires, fresh dirt, or an odd object could signal grave danger.

More in Startups