KorvaJoin the waitlist
Parenting

When Your Teen Lies, Ask What Got in the Way of the Truth

Psychologist Lisa Damour says starting with “you and I both know that’s not true” avoids another lie and opens a talk about why honesty felt hard.

AI image
Ask Lisa: Untangling Family Life · 297: Why Teens Lie—and How to Respond Without Escalating

Psychologist Lisa Damour has a script for the moment a parent has proof that a teenager lied, and it avoids the gotcha.

Borrowing from psychologist Haim Ginott, she advises starting with, “You and I both know that’s not true.” It states the fact without anger, and without asking a question you already know the answer to.

That restraint matters, she says, because asking “Were you at the party?” when you know they were there invites another lie. Opening with “I caught you lying” invites a defensive response.

The line is only the setup. Damour says the more important move comes next: “what got in the way of you telling me?” That question assumes the teen wants to be honest, and that something stood between the teen and that choice.

The same language works when a teen leaves out something important, such as failing to mention that the parents would not be home. Damour suggests saying, “you and I both know I would have wanted to know that the parents were not home for that party.” Then asking, “What got in the way of telling me that?” The goal is to stay connected, not to call the teen on the carpet in a way that prompts denial.

If the answer is “I don’t know,” take it seriously. Damour says the teen may not know yet or may not have thought it through. Tell them you get that this is tricky to answer on the spot, and that you will set aside time tomorrow to talk it through.

Ask them to think before then about what happened and what would keep it from happening again. It treats a good kid who made a bad choice as capable of figuring out the truth.

Questions people ask

Should there still be a consequence for lying?

Give one clear, related consequence, and link it to rebuilding trust. Damour elsewhere ties freedom to demonstrated trustworthiness, so a teen may stay closer to home for a while and earn more independence by showing honesty over time.

What if I suspect a lie but cannot prove it?

Do not stage the same confrontation. Signal doubt calmly without calling the teen a liar, and focus on the practical stakes. If the claim is about homework or practice, note that the cost of not doing the work will fall on the teen.

How do I make my teen more likely to tell the truth next time?

Look at your own part. If honesty has brought a harsh reaction in the past, admit it and apologize, and say you want to make truth telling safer.

More in Parenting