KorvaJoin the waitlist
Tech

Why Election Researchers Say Rumor Instead of Misinformation

In a fast-moving vote count, they often cannot yet tell what is true or whether anyone meant to deceive.

Behind the Bastards · It Could Happen Here Weekly 257

Picture a photo of a ballot box circulating online with a claim of fraud. Researchers watching in real time have a problem: they do not yet know if the photo is real, what it shows, or why the person posted it.

That uncertainty is why Danielle Lee Thompson, a researcher at the University of Washington's Center for an Informed Public, says her team talks about rumors, not misinformation. She defined a rumor as "an unfounded claim or speculation" that has not been verified yet, the kind of thing that spreads naturally when everyone wants to know what happened.

The other words make judgments the team often cannot make in the moment. Disinformation means false information spread on purpose to mislead, for gain or as part of a coordinated effort. Misinformation means false or misleading information shared without necessarily meaning to deceive, like passing along an AI-made image before learning it was fake.

"A rumor actually is maybe a little bit more honest to describe what we're studying in the moment, because we don't know the intent oftentimes," Thompson said. Her colleague Stephen Prohaska put it more bluntly: in rapid response work, "We don't know facticity. We don't know intentionality."

Thompson said the center's founders began by studying crisis informatics, how information flows online during crisis moments. Thompson said, "It's like playing a game of telephone," and noted researchers have studied rumor-spreading in the United States for basically the past 100 years.

Most election rumors are not invented from nothing, Prohaska said. They usually start with something real, a photo, a video, or a lawsuit, and then misread it. One example this cycle ties Elon Musk, texts about lasers in space, and Starlink to voting machines, turning a possible conflict of interest into a theory about manipulation without solid evidence.

That is why the team treats rumor as a working tool. It lets them track a claim while the facts and motives are still unclear, then sort out later whether it turned out to be true, false, or somewhere in between.

Questions people ask

What should I check before sharing an election photo or video?

Look for the original source, date, and place, and check whether election officials or credible local reporters have confirmed it. Be wary when a photo or video is cropped, has no context, or is presented as proof of a large effect without numbers to support it.

Can a rumor turn out to be true?

Yes. A rumor is an unverified claim, not necessarily a false one. Researchers say rumors can prove true, false, or partly true, which is another reason they avoid labeling everything misinformation at first.

Why don't researchers just wait until they know the truth?

By the time every detail is settled, millions of people may already have seen the claim and acted on it. Tracking it as a rumor lets researchers watch how it spreads and correct the record early, then update the judgment as evidence comes in.

More in Tech