Why Rational Investors Ride Bubbles They Suspect Are Unfounded
Past booms suggest manias are not only about gullible buyers, hyped headlines, or easy fixes from officials.

doi.org · Financial History and Financial EconomicsEvidence from Britain's South Sea bubble offers a puzzle. Investors described as rational stayed invested despite believing prices had detached from underlying business values.
Such booms and reversals are rare, so economists look to financial history for more cases to study. The question is whether they can be accounted for by rational causes, including new technology and myopia, or by irrational behaviour or naivete on the part of investors.
Fundamentals is the shorthand for that reality check. It means what companies can plausibly earn and what their assets are plausibly worth over time.
In the South Sea bubble, the evidence points to calculation rather than simple mistake. Investors acting rationally stayed in that episode even while judging that prices lacked support in likely earnings.
That may help explain how a boom can persist after doubts appear. If enough investors expect to sell before a fall, their continued buying can keep prices elevated for a time.
Two other findings concern blame and remedies. A study of the British railway mania, the mid-19th-century rush into rail shares, looked at newspaper coverage and found the press was not to blame for hyping the shares.
A study of the stock market boom in 1920s Germany emphasized the dangers when governments or central banks try to puncture a boom.
Questions people ask
If investors know prices are too high, why do they not just sell?
They may expect to sell to someone else before prices fall, so leaving early means leaving money on the table. That timing game can be rational for one investor, but when many investors play it at once, prices can climb far beyond what companies can earn.
Does that mean the media never causes bubbles?
No. The finding applies to Britain's railway mania, where researchers found the press did not hype railway shares. News coverage can matter in other booms, but this case warns against assuming headlines alone create a bubble.
Why would trying to pop a bubble be dangerous?
The paper does not give a reason. It only reports that the study of 1920s Germany emphasized the dangers of intervention to prick a boom. From this source alone, the specific harm is unstated.


