KorvaJoin the waitlist
Money

Traders Understood Option Pricing Before Black-Scholes Existed

Early investors already grasped what drives option values, raising questions about the idea that the formula created the boom.

AI image
doi.org · Financial History and Financial Economics

A study of old trading records from the Johannesburg Stock Exchange found investors grasped what drives option values 60 years before economists derived the famous formula for pricing them.

An option is a contract whose value depends on a stock's future price. The Black-Scholes-Merton formula is the mathematical method economists later devised to calculate what that contract should be worth today.

Another analysis found South Sea subscription shares, installment contracts that worked much like options, were rationally priced during Britain's 1720 South Sea speculative crash.

That accuracy calls into question the standard story that creation of the formula caused the later growth of option markets.

Research on old markets also shows the hands-on methods dealers relied on to set prices, both before the formula arrived and after it became widely known. Historical settings also let researchers compare how trading arrangements and regulations shaped options trading.

Questions people ask

What actually determines what an option should cost?

The main drivers are the stock's current price relative to the agreed deal price, how much time is left before the option expires, and how volatile the stock is. Higher volatility and more time generally make an option more valuable, because there is a greater chance the price will move in the holder's favor.

How could traders get prices right without the math?

They watched market prices, learned from repeated deals, and adjusted for what seemed to matter, such as time left and risk. Over time, practical rules of thumb can get very close to a mathematical formula, especially when traders who misprice lose money and quickly correct course.

If the formula did not create the market, what helped options take off?

Standardized contracts, clearinghouses that guaranteed trades, clearer trading rules, and later computers made options easier and safer to trade. The formula helped by giving dealers a common language and a way to manage risk, but it was not starting from zero.

More in Money