KorvaJoin the waitlist
Money

Your Extra $10,000 Means About $150 to Your Agent, So a Fast Sale Wins

In sales data from the time, agents kept their own houses listed about 10 days longer and got higher prices, when an extra $10,000 meant about $150 to them.

AI image
GoldenKey · Freakonomics Asks: Does your real estate agent have your best interest in mind?

Imagine you list your house at $300,000 and get an offer for $290,000 the same day. Would you rather take it now, or wait a week for the full price?

In the example, the person playing the agent says, "the bird in the hand is worth two in the bush," and warns that the market is softening.

The agent will also say your interests are aligned. Since the agent is paid a commission, a share of the sale price, a higher price should be good for both of you.

The math says otherwise. An extra $10,000 for you creates $600 in extra commission at the standard 6% rate.

That $600 does not go to your agent. Half goes to the buyer's agent, leaving $300, and then your agent shares that with the brokerage firm.

What is left is about $150, or 1.5% of the extra $10,000. For that $150, the agent would have to keep showing the house for another week, pay for more marketing, and delay finding the next client who could bring a full commission.

Closing fast and moving on is more profitable than waiting. That is why the agent has a strong reason to call the first offer a great one.

The sales data cited at the time pointed to the same incentive. When agents sold their own houses, rather than a client's house, they kept them listed about 10 days longer on average and got a higher price.

When every extra dollar went into their own pocket, waiting suddenly seemed worth the week.

Agents are not bad for acting this way. They are human, and humans respond to incentives, so knowing what someone gains from each choice is often the best clue to what they will advise.

Questions people ask

How does an extra $10,000 turn into $150 for the agent?

The standard commission is 6% of the price, so $10,000 more brings $600 more in commission. Half of that typically goes to the buyer's agent, and the seller's agent then splits the remainder with the brokerage firm, leaving about $150.

What did the data show when agents sold their own houses?

In the sales data described in the July 2016 piece, agents kept their own houses listed about 10 days longer on average and got higher prices than for comparable client houses. At the time, when the extra money went directly to the owner rather than being split as a commission, holding out was financially worthwhile.

Do all sellers pay agents the same way?

Some sellers have arranged flat fees, lower percentages, or bonuses for beating a price target. Each structure changes how much an extra week of work is worth to the agent in dollars. Economists describe these arrangements as attempts to line up incentives more closely.

Are quick offers always lower than later ones?

No. In some markets, early offers turned out to be the highest ones, especially when few buyers were looking. Sales records of the time also showed how long similar nearby houses stayed listed and whether extra time on the market brought higher prices.

More in Money