KorvaJoin the waitlist
Startups

A Crude 90-Day Gut Check for Judging a New Hire

He calls it crude advice: ask how you would feel if today were their last day, before attachment sets in.

AI image
Dalton + Michael · Why Your Startup Shouldn’t Hire Like Google

Michael, a guest on a show about startup hiring, offers what he calls "very crude advice" for judging a new hire.

About three months after someone starts, put a private reminder on your own calendar for yourself alone.

When that reminder appears, ask how you would feel if that employee said today was the last day because they were leaving for Google or OpenAI.

The strong-fit reaction, he says, is a sick feeling in the stomach at the thought of losing them.

Anything short of that sense of loss is a signal to examine the fit more closely.

He jokes that feeling relieved is the dreaded outcome, and a sign the founder likely needs to act.

Three months is enough time to tell whether someone has become invaluable, in his view, and early enough to trust the gut reaction.

That timing matters because attachment builds the longer someone stays, and that attachment makes an honest call harder later.

Keeping a struggling person in the wrong job does not help that person either, he argues, since it leaves both the company and the employee worse off.

Questions people ask

Why does the check use 90 days instead of six months or a year?

Ninety days is usually enough time to see real work, reliability, and how someone collaborates. It is also early enough that a founder has not developed strong personal loyalty that can cloud judgment about performance.

What should a founder do if the reaction is not a strong sense of loss?

Look more closely at the work, gather feedback, and have a direct conversation about what is missing. If the gap reflects a poor fit for the role, a clear exit with severance and help finding a better job is often kinder than letting the person struggle.

Should you tell the new hire about the reminder?

No. The reminder is meant as a private prompt for honest self-reflection, not a performance review. Sharing it in advance would likely create anxiety and make the founder's own reaction less candid.

More in Startups