Firing a Struggling Employee Can Be Kinder Than Keeping Them
Startup advisers say an honest exit with support beats a false kindness that leaves the worker, the boss, and the team miserable.

Dalton + Michael · Why Your Startup Shouldn’t Hire Like GoogleDalton and Michael, who advise startup founders on hiring, were talking about why bosses avoid letting people go.
Everyone wants “to feel like the hero in their own story,” they said, and wants people to like them and avoid hurting feelings.
Then came the line they kept returning to: “isn't it more compassionate to have the honest conversation with them give them great severance help them find the thing that they're going to actually like doing.”
Hiring carries a responsibility to act when the fit is wrong. Bringing someone on means signing up for that possibility, in the way having a child means accepting responsibility.
That responsibility starts with getting comfortable with the idea that suggesting someone do something else does not make a founder a bad person. “If it's not a good fit, they're probably having a bad time too,” they said.
Keeping the person anyway amounts to false kindness. The founder protects a self-image as a kind person, while the boss is miserable, the employee is miserable, and coworkers are not having fun.
The comparison was to a school classroom where one student keeps disrupting and the teacher fails to step in. The rest of the class ends up suffering and wishing the person in charge would take responsibility.
Questions people ask
What does a compassionate firing actually look like?
Be direct, brief, and respectful, explain that the role is not the right fit, and avoid relitigating every mistake. Offer a clear severance payment, continued health coverage where possible, and practical help such as introductions and references.
How can a manager tell a poor fit from someone who just needs more time?
Look for a pattern after clear expectations, coaching, and enough time to learn. If performance, enthusiasm, or working relationships do not improve, and the person seems unhappy or drained, the problem is more likely fit than newness.
Does letting someone go really lift the mood of the team?
Often yes, when the process is handled fairly and the reasons are explained to the remaining team without sharing private details. Relief usually comes because uncertainty lifts, standards become clearer, and workloads or conflicts caused by the mismatch ease.
