Hiring an Outside Sales or Marketing Chief Will Probably Fail, Promoting an Insider Probably Won't
Startup advisers put outsider sales and marketing chiefs below 20%, compared with about 80% for homegrown promotions.

Dalton + Michael · Why Your Startup Shouldn’t Hire Like GoogleDalton and Michael, who advise startup founders, were joking about a familiar piece of investor advice: hire seasoned executives to grow up fast. Dalton opened with a tease to Michael, "So, you start. Why do you love execs?"
They said this advice gets repeated widely and they think it comes from investors. The version they described tells founders to bring in someone who has done it before, someone more experienced than anyone on the team, from fancy companies, and very expensive, to lead and scale the business.
The hosts said the lived experience most founders report with this type of hire is pretty bad. As they put it, founders have "not a lot of incentive" to go on podcasts about bad executive hires, adding, "They just tell us this in office hours," and, "we hear over and over again."
Dalton said the odds depend on the role. For sales and marketing leaders who are true strangers, he and Michael put first-time success at 20% or less, possibly in the single digits. They called a 50% success rate for engineers great by comparison.
A bad hire costs the founder far more time than the hire itself, they argue. Managing, disciplining, and firing a struggling executive team can go from taking none of a founder's time to taking 60% of it. The new executive often brings in his or her own people, which turns one bad hire into a wider mess.
Then Michael asked what succeeds far more often. Dalton's answer was, "Promoting your best homegrown people."
The pair put that success rate at more like 80%, not 100%. The promoted person is already hired, already known, and already part of the culture, so much of what can go wrong with a stranger does not apply. Promoting also delays the moment when an outsider arrives wanting to hire a crowd and reorganize everything.
Questions people ask
Why do outside executives fail so often at startups?
They do not know the startup, its product, or its people, and the startup does not know them. A sales or marketing leader may also try to repeat what worked at a large company, with more money, staff, and brand recognition, instead of learning what works when none of those exist.
How can a founder tell if someone is ready to be promoted into a leadership role?
Look for strong performance, good judgment, and trust among coworkers over a sustained period. The person should already do parts of the job informally, want the responsibility, and understand how decisions get made inside the company.

