A Friday Regular Who Wanted Only Laura's Table Led Police to a Dentist
Police canvassed dozens of medical offices without naming the crime, until the dentist called back and mentioned a homicide.

Dateline NBC · HuntedLaura McNaughton, who worked serving tables at the Rib Crib in Clovis, New Mexico, was visiting family in San Diego for Thanksgiving when her phone rang.
A coworker was calling to say a man had come into the restaurant, asked specifically for Laura, and insisted on being seated where she served.
Then he walked out, unwilling to stay or be served by anyone else. That outburst gave investigators a lead to a regular customer who coworkers said was fixated on Laura.
Coworkers said the man came in only on Fridays, always asked for Laura's section, had a beer, flirted with her, and left her a large cash tip. He would then disappear until the next Friday.
They described him as a young white man in his mid-30s, with blond hair, who always arrived in medical scrubs. To them, he seemed fixated on her, and Laura herself had told her family the attention felt weird.
With no name, investigators set up what the district attorney, Matt Chandler, called a war room at the Clovis police department. They listed every doctor, dentist, and medical practice they could find, filling a dry erase board with dozens and dozens of names.
Detectives fanned out to every clinic and hospital in town, said investigator David Loera. They left cards, gave the description, and asked if anyone matched it, without saying they were investigating a killing.
One card was left at a health clinic with offices in Clovis and in Portales, about 20 miles away. That visit produced a return call that surprised everyone.
The caller was James Smith, a dentist at the clinic. Chandler, who knew Smith from church and community circles, called him back, and Smith said he was returning the detective's visit about the homicide that had happened over the weekend.
Loera said no one had mentioned a murder to the clinics. On a muted phone, the investigators noted that Smith had volunteered a detail they had not given, and that he matched the description they were chasing.
Smith was a married father of two, with a third child on the way, from a well-off and prominent local family involved in church, business, and civic groups. A detective remembered him from high school football as a tough player.
Then Laura's mother, Lucky Beardmore, added the account that tied it together. About six months before she was killed, Laura had called after a dentist appointment to say the dentist had flirted with her and made her uncomfortable.
The next day, Laura called again, startled. The same dentist was now at her workplace. Her mother thought he may have learned where she worked from information Laura left at the dental office.
After hearing that, investigators believed the dentist was the customer they had been trying to find, James Smith.
Questions people ask
What happened to James Smith after he was identified?
Smith later entered what is called an Alford plea to murder, kidnapping, and attempted sexual assault. That means he acknowledged prosecutors had enough evidence to convict him without admitting guilt. He received life plus 27 years.
What kind of restaurant was the Rib Crib?
The Rib Crib is a barbecue restaurant chain with locations in several states. Laura worked as a server at the Clovis restaurant, where regular customers knew her by name and could ask for her section.
How did police connect Smith to Laura's death beyond the restaurant tip?
Investigators later found blood belonging to Laura on Smith's truck, along with other physical evidence. Chandler and Loera said that evidence, combined with Smith's shifting account of the night, moved the case from suspicion to arrest.


