A Washington Man Said His Trash Hole Swallowed 15 Miles of Line
Dogs refused to go near it, candy came back dry, and one checked look-alike proved to be an ordinary well.

The Why Files · America Is Hiding Something UndergroundFor years, Mel Waters used a round pit on his property west of Ellensburg, Washington, as a dump.
Garbage, broken appliances, and old tires went in, and his neighbors threw in theirs too. The pit measured 9 feet 9 inches across, with a stone retaining wall running about 15 feet down before darkness took over.
After a while, Waters started to ask the obvious question: why doesn't it fill up. He concluded the pit had no bottom.
He said he proved it with fishing line. He said he lowered more than 15 miles of line into it without hitting anything.
Waters was an avid fisherman with spools of line on hand. He tied a one-pound weight to a 4,500-foot spool, sent it down, and felt no bottom.
He wound that spool back in and tried again with a roll of Life Savers attached, to test for water. If there had been water below, the candy would have dissolved, but it came back dry.
He kept joining spools, each 5,000 feet long, and kept lowering. At nearly 10,000 feet there was still nothing, and by the time he ran out of line he said he was 80,000 feet down, more than 15 miles, with no bottom.
Along the way, he said the hole behaved strangely. His dogs would not go near it and dug in their feet when forced, no wildlife or insects gathered there, birds flew around it, and his radio picked up odd signals.
For years, people have tried to find the hole, and no one has. One widely shared candidate looked right, about nine feet wide with a stone wall and old buildings on the property, but a visit showed it was an ordinary well with a definite bottom.
Researchers found no local record of a Melvin Waters living there, though supporters say he used a false name. Waters did not supply the photos requested by Art Bell, the radio host who took his calls, saying he forgot or would send them later, and an open hole miles deep would collapse under its own weight.
Yet he never tried to cash in with shirts, books, or phony photos, and his basic account stayed consistent. So the hole sits where it started, somewhere between a tall tale and a real mystery, still unfound.
Questions people ask
Could a 15-mile-deep open hole actually exist?
No. The deepest hole ever drilled, the Kola well in Russia, reached about 7.5 miles before heat and pressure stopped work. An open pit 15 miles deep would collapse under the weight of the surrounding rock, and the rock that deep is hot enough to flow and close any gap.
Where was the hole supposed to be?
He placed it on his property on Manastash Ridge, west of Ellensburg in central Washington. That is rugged, rural country with scattered private parcels, old wells, and mining pits, which helps explain why look-alikes keep turning up and why no confirmed site has emerged.
Why do people still hunt for it if the geology says it is impossible?
Partly because the measurements are so specific, down to the line length and the candy test, and partly because Waters did not sell souvenirs or books. A precise, unprofitable story that cannot be checked is hard to kill, and hard to prove.


