A Handyman Turned Lunch Into An Axe Murder At Taliesin
After serving lunch, Julian Carlton asked for gasoline to clean rugs, then used it to trap diners in a burning room and hunt them with an axe.

Stuff You Should Know · Selects: The Tailesin MassacreOn Saturday, August 15, 1914, Mamah Borthwick sat down for a midday meal on the terrace at Taliesin, the Wisconsin home built by Frank Lloyd Wright, the architect with whom she lived.
With her were her two children, John, 10, and Martha, 8. Their father, Edwin Cheney, Mamah's former husband, had allowed the frequent visits.
Inside the house, six more people sat down in the dining room. They were Wright employees Emile Brodell, Thomas Brunker, David Lindblom, Herbert Fritz, and foreman William Weston, plus Weston's son Ernst.
Seven of those nine people would be dead. The killer was the house handyman, and he used gasoline and an axe to trap and hunt them.
Julian Carlton had been acting strangely for weeks. He grew aggressive and argumentative, talked about killing people, and kept a hatchet at his bedside at night.
His wife, Gertrude, confirmed the behavior. There were rumors that Carlton was about to be dismissed, though the couple already had plans to look for work in Chicago.
That day Carlton served lunch to Mamah and then to the men in the dining room. As they began to eat, he asked Weston for gasoline from the shed, saying he wanted to clean rugs with it. Weston agreed.
Carlton returned with gasoline and an axe. He killed Mamah and her children on the terrace, splashed fuel beneath the doors to the dining room and lit the building ablaze with the diners trapped inside.
Then he circled to a dining room window. As burned men jumped out to escape the flames, he met them outside and struck them with the axe.
The first to get away was draftsman Herb Fritz. He ran with David Lindblom about a half mile to a neighbor's house with a phone to call for help.
Lindblom had been so badly burned that he later died. Weston was struck with the axe and left for dead, but survived.
Wright himself was in Chicago, finishing work on Midway Gardens with his son John Lloyd Wright. When the call came, John Lloyd Wright later wrote he remembered “an unnatural silence when the phone call came in, except for his father's labored breathing.”
Then Wright said, “John, a taxi. Taliesin is on fire.” He had not yet heard about the killings, and learned the details from reporters shouting questions as he headed for the train. A Chicago headline called it The End of Lawless Loves.
Questions people ask
What happened to Julian Carlton?
Carlton was found hours later in an asbestos-lined boiler room in the basement. He had drunk hydrochloric acid in an apparent suicide attempt, but survived both the fire and the poison. He died in jail seven weeks later after the acid destroyed his throat and stomach.
What was Taliesin, and is it still standing?
Taliesin, near Spring Green, Wisconsin, was Wright's home, studio, and farm estate. Wright rebuilt the living quarters after the 1914 fire, and the property later suffered another major fire in 1925. It remains preserved today as a museum, school site, and National Historic Landmark.
Who was Mamah Borthwick?
Borthwick had been a client's wife when she met Wright around 1903, and their affair led both to leave their spouses in 1909. She lived openly with Wright at Taliesin despite widespread public disapproval. She had left her two children in her former husband's care, and they were visiting her when they were killed.


