KorvaJoin the waitlist
Psychology

A Historian's Account of Why Some Mexican American Voters Opposed Illegal Immigration

In Victor Davis Hanson's account, a mother's encounter with police, deportation, and a threatening call shows how safety and crowded services shaped some voters' views.

AI image
Uncommon Knowledge · The Counter Revolution: Victor Davis Hanson on the Fall and Rise of Trump (Part 1/2)

The call came after a gang member threatened her son. A Mexican American mother called the police about the threat.

The officers told her they could do little. They said hers was a sanctuary city, a place where local police limit cooperation with federal immigration officers.

Victor Davis Hanson, a historian at Stanford's Hoover Institution and author discussing President Donald Trump's appeal to working voters, retold her story to make a broader point. In Hanson's account, many Mexican American voters opposed illegal immigration because they felt its costs most directly.

Part of his argument was about community. Hanson said about half the migrants arriving from Spanish speaking countries were not from Mexico, including about two million Venezuelans plus Colombians and others from the Caribbean, and many Mexican Americans felt little shared identity with them.

The other part was about daily life. Hanson said families already had mothers in dialysis clinics and sons in crowded high schools, and services were being overwhelmed. Some children of longtime residents, he said, were even mocked as outsiders and asked why they did not speak Spanish.

In the mother's case, Hanson said, police finally passed word to federal agents off the record. Officers with Immigration and Customs Enforcement, the federal agency that detains and deports people in the country illegally, arrested the man and deported him.

Relief did not last. Hanson said the man called the mother from deep in Oaxaca, in southern Mexico, and told her he was coming back, leaving her terrified.

She told Hanson she lived on a road where gangs had traded gunfire very close to her home, with her brother caught near it during a clash between northern and southern Latino gangs. In Hanson's view, the burden was falling on Hispanic neighborhoods, while support for the policy came from white coastal liberals.

Hanson said tougher enforcement later changed the calculation because people were afraid of Immigration and Customs Enforcement. He said he had predicted that this issue alone would carry Trump to victory.

Questions people ask

What is a sanctuary city?

A sanctuary city or county generally limits how much local police help federal immigration officers. Police still respond to crimes, but they may not ask about immigration status or hold someone for immigration agents. Supporters say the policy builds trust, while critics say it lets repeat offenders avoid deportation.

What does ICE do?

Immigration and Customs Enforcement is the federal agency that enforces immigration laws inside the United States. Its officers arrest, detain, and remove people who are here illegally, especially after a crime or a final deportation order. Local police sometimes share information with the agency, unless local rules restrict cooperation.

Why might Mexican Americans feel little connection to other Spanish speaking migrants?

Spanish is spoken in more than 20 countries, and national histories, foods, accents, and traditions differ widely. A Mexican American family with deep roots in California or Texas may feel little in common with a newly arrived Venezuelan or Colombian. Hanson argued that outsiders wrongly assumed a single shared identity based on language.

More in Psychology