KorvaJoin the waitlist
Psychology

Trump Would Not Soften His Accent, and Workers Noticed

Historian Victor Davis Hanson argues that refusing to soften his voice made Trump seem authentic to tradesmen.

AI image
Uncommon Knowledge · The Counter Revolution: Victor Davis Hanson on the Fall and Rise of Trump (Part 1/2)

Victor Davis Hanson, a classical historian who farms in California's San Joaquin Valley, was trying to explain Donald Trump's pull with working men.

He had just argued that Trump was building a class movement, not a racial one. Then he turned to authenticity. In Hanson's words: "whatever he is, he is."

Hanson meant that Trump did not adjust himself for the room. Other politicians changed their accents, Hanson argued, pointing to Hillary Clinton, Kamala Harris, and Barack Obama.

Trump kept what Hanson called that grating Queens delivery wherever he went. In Tulare, California, Hanson said, Trump did not put on a Caterpillar hat or a work vest.

Hanson said, "He came out with a black suit, a red tie, wingtips, the orange makeup, and the grating."

To Hanson, the message voters heard was that Trump was not trying to be anything other than himself.

Hanson said he saw that reaction near home. He lives, he said, in a community that is 95 percent Hispanic, and he talked politics with neighbors all the time.

The kids headed to Fresno State disliked Trump, he said, as did many Hispanic government workers, mostly women. But the drywall man, the electrician, the plumber, and the tractor driver almost all liked him because he seemed authentic.

The other part was refusal to backtrack. Hanson said voters were watching younger left wing candidates sanitize old posts and explain away old remarks, while Trump said outrageous things and, in Hanson's account, added that is the way he feels.

That bluntness could be crude, Hanson acknowledged. He pointed to Trump's remark after the death of actor and director Rob Reiner, a fierce critic, that he did not miss him.

To many working people, Hanson said, the crudeness mattered less than the refusal to squirm. They were tired, in his telling, of people apologizing and saying they did not really mean it.

Questions people ask

What does a Queens accent sound like?

Queens is a borough of New York City, and its accent is part of the broader New York sound. It is often marked by dropped r sounds, flattened vowels, and a fast, nasal delivery that many Americans associate with outer borough toughness.

Who is Victor Davis Hanson?

Hanson is a classicist known for writing about ancient Greek warfare, a fellow at Stanford's Hoover Institution, and a farmer in central California. He has written more than 20 books, including a recent book on Trump's return to office.

Why would voters reward a politician for not apologizing?

Hanson argues that many working class voters hear constant apologies as evasive or elite. In that setting, he says, a politician who stands by a blunt remark can look honest, even to voters who dislike the remark itself.

More in Psychology