KorvaJoin the waitlist
Psychology

Older Judges Guard Speech, Younger Americans See Harm

A law professor says today's Supreme Court likely sides with speakers, but generational change and new technology could reshape doctrine.

AI image
Original Jurisdiction · The Disappointed Originalist: Sherif Girgis

Sherif Girgis, a law professor moving from Notre Dame Law School to Harvard Law School in January, was asked where free speech law is headed.

Girgis spoke of "younger people on both the left and the right" who are "quicker to think that speech might cause harms of the kind that we're in a position to regulate and that we should be regulating."

By contrast, he argued, older Americans, including much of the federal bench and the Supreme Court, favor a very robust regime. They want ideas to compete freely, and Girgis said they are "very wary of government trying to put a thumb on the scale, much less censor," and apply stringent protections almost categorically.

That is why, Girgis said, if all you know is that a free speech case reached today's Supreme Court, his guess is "that the free speech claimant wins." The details matter, but that is his prior.

But this court will not sit forever, he added, and strong precedent is no guarantee. Doctrine can always be manipulated, he said, especially when a categorical rule feels like it proves too much. He called what happens in 20 years an open question.

Girgis said he shares the strong pro-speech priors behind the current court's approach. He does not doubt that speech can cause real harm, to reputations, to important causes, and to what he called our moral ecology.

Still, Girgis said he is "a little bit more comfortable than the current court" in calling some speech worthless and regulable. He pointed to videos that depict cruelty to animals for entertainment, at issue in a case from about 16 years ago, and to computer-generated sexual material involving minors.

He sees the next questions as open ones involving scale and technology.

Girgis said artificial intelligence and social media platforms involve changes of a scale the court has not had to address in prior cases, raising questions about how past precedents apply.

All else equal, he said, he wants to "err on the side of leaving as much room for debate as possible."

Questions people ask

Why is today's Supreme Court so protective of free speech?

In recent decades the Court has treated content-based restrictions with deep suspicion, requiring the government to satisfy strict scrutiny in most cases. Only a few narrow historical categories, like incitement, true threats, and obscenity, receive less protection. That framework usually favors the speaker.

What was the animal-crush videos case?

Congress passed a federal law banning depictions of animal cruelty, and the Court struck it down in 2010 as substantially overbroad. The 8 to 1 decision said the government cannot create a new unprotected category simply by balancing speech value against social cost. Girgis said he would have been comfortable upholding that kind of regulation.

How could AI and social media change free speech law?

The main questions involve state action, scale, and editorial control. Courts are being asked when platform moderation counts as government action, when algorithmic amplification changes the analysis, and how to apply older doctrines about public debate to AI-generated expression. None has a settled answer yet.

More in Psychology