A Noncitizen Vote Is Often a Paperwork Mistake, Not Always Intent
The Justice Department charged 28 green card holders in California, about 0.0001 percent of registered voters, in cases researchers say often start with confusion.

Up First from NPR · Pushback On Trump's Russia Policy, Competitive Midterm Races, DOJ Noncitizen VotingFor an immigrant holding a green card, one extra vote can put a future at risk. That trade hangs over a California voting dispute from mid-October that centered on about 20,000 names on the voter rolls, with 28 people charged.
Around Oct. 13, Justice Department officials handed Los Angeles County a thumb drive with 20,000 names from voter rolls statewide, saying those people were likely noncitizens. The department asked the county and the state to separate those ballots and leave them uncounted until each person could be investigated.
California says the federal government offered no evidence for the claim, and that doing what it asks would likely violate state and federal law. As reported, no court had granted the request, and election law experts were skeptical a court would order such a change after ballots had already gone out.
The department then announced charges against 28 green card holders, immigrants permitted to live and work permanently in the United States, who allegedly registered to vote. NPR elections reporter Miles Parks put that number in context. The 28 people account for roughly 0.0001 percent of California's registered voters.
Parks said, "Research has found that in many of these cases where legal permanent residents do register to vote, it's often found to be because of bureaucratic errors or because they didn't realize it was illegal." He added, "It just usually does not make that much sense that someone would risk their chance at permanent citizenship to cast one vote."
Election experts worried that high profile charges could still leave a different impression. As early voting got underway in October, they said, a case involving dozens could make noncitizen voting sound far more common than the numbers show.
Questions people ask
Can green card holders vote in federal elections?
No. Only U.S. citizens may vote in federal elections. Green card holders may live and work in the country permanently, and they pay taxes, but they cannot vote for president or Congress until they become citizens.
Can noncitizens ever vote legally anywhere in the U.S.?
Yes, in a very small number of cities and only for local offices such as school board. Those local rules do not change the federal ban on voting in federal elections.



