KorvaJoin the waitlist
Money

More 401(k) Choices Were Linked to Less Saving, or None at All

Those who did enroll with dozens of funds to pick from were more likely to avoid stocks or hide entirely in cash.

AI image
TED · Sheena Iyengar: How to make choosing easier

Offer American workers just two funds in their 401(k), the workplace retirement savings plan, and participation ran in the mid-70s percent. Offer nearly 60 funds, and it fell to about 60 percent.

That pattern comes from retirement saving by nearly a million Americans across 657 U.S. plans. The plans ranged from offering two funds to 59 funds, and more funds went with lower enrollment.

It also went with more cautious choices among those who did enroll. The more funds available, the more likely workers were to avoid stocks entirely or to put everything in money market accounts.

Behavioral scientist Sheena Iyengar, who did the study with colleagues, said neither extreme was a good decision for people's future financial well-being.

Questions people ask

What exactly is a 401(k)?

A 401(k) lets American workers put part of each paycheck into investments for retirement, often with matching money from the employer. With a traditional 401(k), contributions come out before income tax and the money grows without tax until it is withdrawn, when it is taxed. Roth 401(k)s are taxed differently.

Why is avoiding stocks or going all cash a bad retirement strategy?

Stocks have historically grown much faster than cash over long periods, despite sharp ups and downs along the way. Money market accounts are safe and stable, but their returns often barely keep up with inflation. Over decades of saving, avoiding stocks can leave a retiree with far less to live on.

More in Money