Ticket Sales Alone Cannot Keep a Symphony Alive
Nashville's stone concert hall is expensive to run, it could not pay the interest on its mortgage, and its savings are a fraction of its peers.

Marketplace · What's in a jobless claim?Even with a full house, a symphony still loses money on the concert.
In classical music, ticket sales were never priced to cover the full cost of putting dozens of highly trained musicians on stage. They are one piece of a larger support system of donations, invested savings, and a manageable building.
In Nashville, the building became the problem. The symphony plays in a large stone concert hall that fills nearly a whole downtown block, built 20 years ago, and the upkeep and management of a place that large is costly.
Debt made it heavier. Major donor Martha Ingram had agreed to take over its mortgage, but after her death in August, it emerged that the symphony had been unable to pay even the interest.
Colleen Wheelahan, a writer who covers classical music, says years of living in the red kept the symphony from building its savings for the future. Comparable orchestras have endowments about ten times the size of Nashville's.
The hall’s location adds friction without adding revenue. Once built to help revive its neighborhood, it now sits in a tourist hotspot, and local patrons at times have waited hours just to leave the parking garage.
That is why fuller crowds cannot fix the math, says Jim White, a former symphony board member. It is too late, he argues, to simply sell more tickets and raise more donations.
Conductor Leonard Slatkin, who previously led major orchestras elsewhere in the United States, says a $10 million gift from Oracle buys time for a restructuring plan. For many orchestras, the remaining choices are structural, including dropping recording projects, shifting musicians to part-time work, or selling property.
Questions people ask
What does an orchestra's endowment actually do?
An endowment is a pool of donated money that is invested, and the orchestra spends a small share of the earnings each year. A large endowment provides steady income for salaries, rent, and programming even when ticket sales dip. A small one leaves an orchestra dependent on each season's fundraising.
Why don't symphonies just charge more for tickets?
Raising prices enough to cover costs would make many seats unaffordable, and attendance would likely fall. Orchestras also see low prices and student tickets as part of their public mission. So they hold ticket prices below cost and ask donors to make up the difference.
Why is a concert hall so expensive to run?
A concert hall needs climate control for instruments, stage crews, lighting and sound staff, cleaning, security, insurance, and constant repair of a large, specialized building. Mortgage or bond payments can add to those fixed costs. The bills arrive whether the hall is full or half empty.

