KorvaJoin the waitlist
Money

A Wharton Professor Says Some Laid-Off Workers Skip Jobless Aid for Same-Day Gig Pay

According to Lindsay Cameron, delivery apps offer faster money than filing for aid that workers may not get.

AI image
Marketplace · What's in a jobless claim?

Jobless claims, the weekly count of new applications for unemployment benefits, have fallen to historic lows, raising questions about what the number still captures. Lindsay Cameron, who teaches management at Wharton, offered one theory about what happens after a layoff.

She was talking about unemployment insurance, usually shortened to UI, the state payments for people who lose jobs. Cameron argued that some people bypass that system entirely.

Lindsay Cameron said, “Instead of trying to get UI, which can be a psychologically demoralizing experience, it's much easier to get on these e-bikes or e-scooters and do DoorDash deliveries, things that don't really require that many assets and can give you instant payout the same day.”

In her account, delivery work asks for little to start. A worker can rent an e-bike or scooter, sign on to an app such as DoorDash, which dispatches drivers to pick up restaurant orders, and collect pay that same day.

Cameron said people in poorly paid jobs and people of color often fall into a gray area, without steady protection under labor law and access to government aid. For them, she said, gig driving can serve as a stand-in paycheck after a layoff.

Her idea fits a broader shift described by Michelle Evermore, of the National Employment Law Project. Evermore said that in many states fewer than 20 percent of unemployed people receive benefits, down from 35 to 40 percent decades ago.

Marketplace reporter Mitchell Hartman noted that more than a dozen states have lowered the longest coverage period to as little as 12 weeks, down from 26.

That delivery story is a theory, not a count of how many workers make that choice. Mark Zandi, chief economist at Moody's Analytics, pointed to other forces that can hold down claims, including laid-off immigrants who might be hesitant to seek government payments and baby boomers retiring.

For now, Cameron argued, the much easier path can be a rented scooter and orders that pay out before the day ends.

Questions people ask

Do gig workers qualify for unemployment benefits?

In most states, regular employees have premiums paid on their wages and can claim benefits if they are laid off. People classified as independent contractors generally cannot, because no employer has paid into the system for them, which excludes much gig and contract work.

How fast is same-day pay on delivery apps?

Most large delivery apps offer weekly direct deposit, plus an option to cash out earnings the same day for a small fee. For a driver who needs gas, rent, or grocery money, that instant payout can feel very different from waiting weeks for a benefits decision.

Why is applying for unemployment often described as demoralizing?

Applicants often must document past wages, prove they left work through no fault of their own, and certify each week that they are searching for jobs. Claims can be delayed or denied, and surveys find that the process leaves many people feeling judged and powerless.

More in Money