A Young Scientist Hid Proof of Failure Under His Sweatshirt to Get It Out of Theranos
After months of ignored warnings, Tyler Shultz decided to keep a copy of his email to Elizabeth Holmes by carrying it out on paper.

Y Combinator · Inside Theranos with ex-Employee Tyler ShultzOn his last morning at Theranos, Tyler Shultz, a young research engineer at the blood testing startup, sat in the break room chatting while he waited to learn whether the company wanted him to leave that day.
He had challenged the company’s founder, Elizabeth Holmes, and its president, Sunny Balwani, about tests that did not work. He had already given two weeks’ notice and offered to leave earlier if they preferred.
His manager told him that Holmes and Balwani thought it was more appropriate if he left that day. The human resources chief summoned him for around 3 o’clock and handed him another secrecy agreement, which he signed without reading.
That meeting was the end of months of warnings that Shultz says were ignored, dismissed, and punished.
Shultz had started by raising concerns in person with colleagues, managers, a vice president, Balwani, Holmes, and a board member. He had also contacted New York health regulators, who told him the company’s testing practices clearly violated the rules.
Holmes, who had been putting off another meeting, told him to put his concerns in an email. He laid out each observation, the data behind it, and what the company should do, and closed by saying he was dedicated to its long term vision.
Holmes forwarded the message to Balwani. His reply, Shultz says, was longer, much of it in red, bold, and capital letters, calling Shultz arrogant, ignorant, and reckless. Shultz recalls Balwani saying that with any other family name, he would already have faced severe punishment. His grandfather was George Shultz, the former U.S. secretary of state and a member of Theranos’s board.
Before giving notice, Shultz had typed an angry resignation, then deleted it. He sent the short note instead.
He was afraid to email himself the long exchange. He says the company also accused him of breaking his agreement over other things he had sent himself: a benign intern presentation to practice at home, and links to published science papers he wanted to read.
So he tried to print it. He pressed print again and again, and nothing came out. Then, with his computer more than 25 yards away, the printer suddenly began spitting out more than a dozen copies of the very long exchange.
He stood over the machine while what he estimated as 200 to 300 pages printed, afraid someone would ask what the ream of paper was. He knew cameras watched every door and the parking lot.
When it stopped, he tucked the stack under his shirt, beneath a sweatshirt he said he almost never wore. He kept a hand under his shirt and walked to his car and put the papers in the trunk.
The escort never came. Human resources had said security would walk him out and bar him from retrieving one or two personal books from his desk, but then said security was busy and told him to walk straight out. He chatted cordially with the guard at the front desk for two minutes and left, a calm exit the company would later describe as storming out.
Questions people ask
What does validation mean in a medical lab?
Validation is the testing a lab must do to prove a medical test gives accurate and reliable results before it is used on patients. Shultz’s job involved running those experiments, and he concluded the company’s device was failing them while patient testing moved forward.
