About 10% Of Americans Think They Are Allergic To Penicillin, But More Than 90% Can Take It Safely
Many substitutes cost more, bring more side effects, and in some cases can fuel drug resistance.

Freakonomics Radio Network · Are You Really Allergic to Penicillin? (Update) | Freakonomics RadioAbout one in 10 Americans believes they are allergic to penicillin, but studies show about 90% of them can tolerate it safely.
Elena Resnik, an allergist, says most were told they had a reaction in childhood. Kimberly Blumenthal, a Mayo Clinic allergy specialist, says "antibiotic allergy is misdiagnosed most of the time" because infections cause rashes, especially in children, and the rash gets blamed on the drug.
In her own practice, Blumenthal saw about 3,000 patients who thought they were allergic over more than a decade and found about 20 who truly were, with two severe reactions she remembers. Allergy researcher Thomas Platts-Mills says a whole generation of doctors was trained thinking "penicillin allergy was very dangerous and very common." He says it is neither.
Blumenthal called the idea that other drugs make penicillin dispensable "100% wrong." She says substitutes cost more, many have more serious side effects and sometimes, as with vancomycin, can increase the risk of drug-resistant bacteria.
Questions people ask
Why does the penicillin allergy label often start in childhood?
Infections themselves produce rashes, especially in children. When the rash appears during treatment with an antibiotic, it is recorded as a drug reaction and stays on the medical chart for decades.
How do allergy clinics check a penicillin allergy label?
Allergy clinics typically start with a skin prick using penicillin ingredients, followed by a small injection under the skin when needed. When those are negative, a supervised dose of amoxicillin by mouth with observation is used to confirm tolerance.
Why do substitute antibiotics cause more problems than penicillin?
Penicillin-family drugs have one of the most benign adverse-effect profiles when the infection is sensitive to them. Alternatives are more expensive, carry more serious complications, and in some cases raise the risk of drug-resistant bacteria.


