KorvaJoin the waitlist
Money

After His Brother Died, He Tied Help to a Budget

He asked his brother's wife and adult daughter to set their own spending plan, then paid it in stipends.

AI image
The Minimalists · 560 | The Responsibility

After his brother died, Joshua Fields Millburn, a co-founder of The Minimalists, said, "I'd give my own life to bring him back." Donations had been raised to help the family, and he said the help needed conditions.

The money was raised through GoFundMe, with help from listeners, to support his brother's wife and three children, one an adult and two tiny. He thanked the listeners who contributed.

He said he would feel great if his only obligation was to pay his brother's rent for a while. Even if doing that somehow brought his brother back, he said, there would still be stipulations around the help.

Just handing the family the money and saying, "Here you go. Good luck with that," would do them a disservice, he said. So he asked his brother's wife and adult daughter to sign an agreement.

Together they put together a budget, and the money would be paid out in stipends based on those terms. He left the spending decisions to them.

As Millburn put it, "what that did is it gave them the dignity of figuring out what their budget was." The spending choices stayed in their hands.

"Sometimes the kindest thing we can give someone is the dignity of their own consequences," he said.

He said he would help within those boundaries, but if they did not make the responsible decision for themselves, there would be consequences he could not save them from. Understanding that upfront was part of the help.

He compared unguided giving to throwing food scraps to someone stuck in a crater. The real way to help, he said, "is to maybe give any additional resources you have, but also show" a way out, whether the person dug the crater or fell in through hard times.

Questions people ask

What is GoFundMe?

GoFundMe is an online fundraising site where people collect donations for personal causes, medical bills, memorials, and other needs. Organizers set up a page describing the need, and donors give directly through the site. Funds typically go to the organizer to distribute.

What did Millburn mean by saying the real way to help is not to just do it for them?

Millburn said simply handing over money would have been a disservice. He said the real way to help is not to do everything for someone, but to give resources and also show a way out. He applied that to his brother's family by tying stipends to a budget they helped create.

What was his comparison about food scraps and a crater?

Millburn compared unguided giving to throwing food scraps to someone stuck in a crater. The image was about keeping someone alive where they are without helping them leave. He said help should include resources plus a path out, whether the person dug the hole or fell in during hard times.

More in Money