KorvaJoin the waitlist
Design

American Politics Is Two Burger Joints Selling the Same Bad Choice

Democrat who ran for Iowa governor Rob Sand said a forced choice between two parties rewards attack politics over results.

AI image
The Ezra Klein Show · The Winning Democrat Who Wants to Break Up Political Parties

Rob Sand, a former corruption prosecutor who ran for Iowa governor as a Democrat, said American politics suffers from constant temptation.

Sand argues that a system with only two choices pulls candidates, elected officials, and consultants toward the easy path. Sand puts it in religious terms, saying, "There's this line in the Lord's Prayer, 'lead us not into temptation,'" as a reminder to avoid what pulls people off the straight and narrow.

"If you had to eat hamburgers and you can only get them at Burger King or McDonald's, they would be telling you the other one is feeding you rat meat."

He borrowed the comparison from the book The Politics Industry, which treats Democrats and Republicans like a shared monopoly in a market where customers must buy. When voters have nowhere else to go, Sand says, neither side has to make a better burger.

Instead, he argues, vast amounts of time, money, and attention go into the two parties beating up on each other rather than solving the everyday problems voters experience. A politician who wants what many people call a successful career, meaning reelection over and over, only has to persuade the public that he or she is the lesser of two evils.

Sand says that setup allows both laziness and corruption. Solving problems is hard, but getting reelected can be easy if a candidate can demonize the opponent enough that voters settle and say, well, I guess I have to vote for this person.

That was his pitch at 200 public town halls during his run for governor. At every one, Sand said millions of people "feel trapped into voting for a candidate they didn't like" because they feared the alternative, which he called "a tremendously corrupting influence on where we're supposed to go."

Questions people ask

Does Sand want America to copy European multiparty systems?

No. He says he does not want to emulate those countries. His argument is simpler: voters should have more meaningful options on the ballot, which does not necessarily require more parties.

What election changes does he support?

He favors one primary ballot open to every voter, with the top three to five finishers advancing to the general election. In that general election, he favors approval voting, where voters may vote for as many candidates as they like, so candidates have reason to treat each other respectfully and earn votes from their rivals' supporters.

Why does he think approval voting would reduce attacks?

If a voter can support several candidates, insulting an opponent can cost you that opponent's second vote. Sand argues that gives candidates an incentive to treat one another respectfully. He prefers it to ranked choice voting, which he calls confusing and slow to count.

More in Design