Automate Only What You Want Done the Same Way Every Time
After blinds that kept reopening themselves, a smart home builder decided variable routines belong on a button.

Foxy's Lab · Your smart home doesn't need more automations. It needs buttonsFoxy, who builds elaborate smart home setups, had just fitted smart blinds and written what looked like a perfect routine. The plan was for it to follow daylight to shut the blinds in the evening, then lift them again so the lights of Canary Wharf were visible after dark.
The automation lasted three days. One night Foxy wanted the blinds properly closed after sunset, shut them, and watched them open again within a minute because the routine checked every minute whether the sun had set.
That failure taught Foxy a rule for the whole house. As Foxy puts it, "The only way an automation makes sense that isn't manually triggered by you is if you want that action to happen every single time that condition is met."
Foxy argues that the blinds did not pass that test. Foxy did not want them closed the same way every night, so a button was more honest than a routine pretending life was predictable.
Yes, Foxy says, the routine could have been patched to stop checking after a certain hour. But Foxy decided against it, reasoning that inevitably there would be another edge case later, and that "automations often have bugs in them."
There was also a simpler observation. If the light was bothering Foxy, Foxy was sitting next to the window, and therefore sitting next to where a button could just be pressed.
That puts Foxy at odds with smart home purists who say a good house should need no touching at all. Foxy disagrees completely, though Foxy still likes motion triggered lights and very specific time based jobs where the same action is wanted every time.
After moving the living room lights and blinds to buttons, Foxy says the room simply feels better to control. Foxy's conclusion is blunt: "Instead of fiddling with automations, choose a button. It's way simpler."
Questions people ask
What kinds of automations are still worth keeping?
Ones where you want the same action every time the condition is met. Foxy specifically names motion-based automations and very specific time-based automations. Foxy did not want the blinds closed the same way every night, so that job failed the test.
Why not just keep adding conditions to fix a broken automation?
Foxy says you could keep patching the routine, but inevitably another edge case will come later. Foxy also says "automations often have bugs in them" so Foxy prefers a button for variable jobs instead of fiddling with exceptions.
Does using a physical button defeat the purpose of a smart home?
No, a smart button still uses the smart home system, it just starts the action when you ask. It can toggle lights, stop moving blinds, or trigger a scene that would take several taps in an app.
