KorvaJoin the waitlist
Psychology

Crossed Arms Do Not Catch Liars, but Word Patterns Can Hint at Evasion

Honest speakers tend to claim their words with I, me, and my, while invented stories get harder to keep straight on retelling.

AI image
The Learning Leader Show With Ryan Hawk · 517: David Lieberman - How To Never Be Lied To Again, Decipher What People Really Think, What They Really Want, & Who They Really Are (Mind Reader)

Forget crossed arms, nose scratching, or averted eyes as lie detectors. Those familiar gestures promise confidence but often mislead.

David Lieberman, a therapist and prolific author, says reliance on those outdated signs produces many false reads.

Part of the problem is that everyone knows them. A sophisticated liar simply avoids the obvious tells and gives nothing away.

The more useful approach, he says, comes from psycholinguistics, the study of how people use language. Instead of one isolated cue, it looks for nine, 10, 11, or 12 markers across a full sentence or conversation.

One marker is pronouns. Research shows that people who believe what they are saying are more likely to take ownership with I, me, or my.

Saying, I like your tie, signals more conviction than saying, nice tie. Removing the speaker from the sentence can suggest weaker belief.

Lieberman stresses that the clue is suggestive, not conclusive. One missing I proves nothing on its own.

A second pattern appears when a story is retold. The truth requires no memorization, just what happened, while a fabrication requires keeping track of invented details.

That is why investigators ask people to go over an account again and watch for inconsistencies. A made up story is hard to keep straight on repetition.

The same effort to manage impressions shows up in poker. A player with a strong hand may deliberate before betting, to suggest weakness, while a bluffer may bet very quickly, to project strength.

The lesson is to watch language over time, not posture in a moment. Distant wording plus shifting details across retellings can hint at evasion.

Questions people ask

Why would saying I make a statement sound more honest?

Using I can signal ownership and lower psychological distance. Saying I think or I did ties the speaker to the claim, while dropping the pronoun can create a little buffer. It is a tendency, not a rule, and confident liars can still say I.

If an honest person misremembers, does retelling still work?

Repeating can help because memory for lived events is usually stable, while invented details must be actively remembered. Still, honest people can misremember dates, sequences, and small facts under stress. One change does not equal a lie, but growing contradictions are worth attention.

Can you spot a poker bluff by how fast someone bets?

Timing can be informative because players often try to project the opposite of their hand. Strong means slow, to look uncertain, and weak means fast, to look confident. Skilled opponents know this too, so they may reverse the pattern and make timing unreliable on its own.

More in Psychology