Crypto Exchanges Hold Your Money Where You Trade
Your stocks sit with a regulated broker, but your crypto can sit with the exchange itself, and may lack the safeguards brokers must have.

Up First from NPR 路 Oil Earnings, Binance Heist, A MAHA UpdateThe Binance theft was the largest crypto heist on record, with billions of dollars taken in an attack widely blamed on North Korean hackers. Reporter Raphael Nam said it is still too early to say whether major flaws in Binance security played a role.
Researchers he spoke with pointed instead to the skill of those hackers. But critics say the setup of crypto exchanges deserves scrutiny on its own.
With stocks, the trading venue and the holder of the money are separate. Amanda Fisher, of the financial advocacy group Better Markets, said: "You may trade on the New York Stock Exchange, but you don't keep your funds with the New York Stock Exchange. You keep it with your broker. And your broker is audited and regulated by the SEC."
The SEC is the Securities and Exchange Commission, the federal agency that oversees brokers. Fisher said the broker also must pay for insurance that makes customers whole after a cyberattack.
Crypto combines those jobs. At an exchange, a customer can buy and sell Bitcoin and also leave that Bitcoin stored in the same place where the trading happens. That piles customer money into one place.
The first consequence is theft. Nam compared it to the line attributed to bank robber Willie Sutton, who supposedly said he robbed banks because that is where the money is. A one stop shop for trading and storage is an inviting target.
The second is weaker protection and temptation from the inside. Nam reported that Binance has promised to repay investors and has frozen about $3 billion, but firms like it are not necessarily bound by the safeguards required of traditional financial institutions.
Fisher said that with client funds close at hand: "It can become almost irresistible to dip into those client funds just this one time, you know, is what they say, to cover their losses." She warned such a step can spiral into disaster for investors. Nam noted it has happened before, most prominently with the exchange FTX, which collapsed in 2022.
Binance says its venue is secure and denies misconduct, but it does not want to meet the same requirements as Wall Street firms. The industry argues crypto is still new and needs lighter rules to expand.
Regulators were strict under former President Joe Biden, and President Donald Trump has promised a much lighter approach. Many consumer advocates now tell Americans that with crypto, it is buyer beware.
Questions people ask
Will people who lost money in the Binance hack get it back?
Binance has promised to repay anyone who lost money and says it has frozen about $3 billion in stolen crypto. Nam reported that such firms are not necessarily bound by the safeguards required of traditional financial firms.
What happened with FTX?
FTX was a large crypto exchange that collapsed in spectacular fashion in 2022. Nam cited it as the most prominent example of the risky behavior Fisher warned about, when an exchange dips into client funds.
What protects me if my stock broker is hacked?
Stock brokers must follow Securities and Exchange Commission rules, including audits and insurance requirements. Most brokers are also members of the Securities Investor Protection Corp., which covers up to $500,000 per customer if a firm fails. This SIPC detail is general background beyond the NPR report, which describes only required audits and insurance that repays customers after a hack.



