KorvaJoin the waitlist
Money

Federal Workers Historically Got a Passing Grade 99.7% of the Time

Among about 7,000 senior executives, roughly 90% get one of the top two ratings.

AI image
The a16z Show · Scott Kupor on Building a16z and Rebuilding the Federal Workforce

Historically, almost every federal worker passed the annual review, with 99.7% rated satisfactory or better.

Scott Kupor, who leads the Office of Personnel Management, the federal government's hiring and personnel agency, says scores run from one to five. A three means an employee is doing what was asked, while a five means "knocking the cover off the ball."

Historically, that left just 0.3% below expectations across a workforce of about 2 million people, a result Kupor calls not mathematically possible.

At the top, the pattern is even starker. Among about 7,000 senior executives, roughly 90% receive one of the two highest ratings, as if nearly everyone is outstanding.

Kupor says the crush at the top breaks the point of bonuses. When almost everyone gets an extra thousand dollars, he argues, it neither rewards the best nor keeps them.

Questions people ask

What does the Office of Personnel Management do?

It is the federal government's central human resources agency. It sets hiring policy, administers benefits and retirement, and oversees performance systems for the civilian workforce.

Is the government trying to change the ratings?

Kupor says OPM now limits top ratings to no more than 40% of a group. The aim, he says, is to make high ratings mean something again and to focus bonus money on true high performers.

Do private companies have the same problem?

Many private employers also struggle with generous ratings, a pattern researchers call leniency bias. Some companies use forced rankings or calibration meetings, but those systems are controversial and can create their own morale problems.

More in Money