KorvaJoin the waitlist
Money

Under Old Rules, a 19-Year-Old Coder Would Have Been Stuck at an Entry-Level Government Job

Kupor argues a degree rule would have kept Ed out or offered only a roughly $40,000 entry job.

AI image
The a16z Show · Scott Kupor on Building a16z and Rebuilding the Federal Workforce

Scott Kupor, who runs the federal government's hiring agency, still remembers the moment he read a quote about a teenage coder. He said he wanted to pull his hair out.

The coder was Ed, widely known online by a crude nickname. At 19, after dropping out of Northwestern as a sophomore, he had joined Elon Musk's government efficiency team as a software developer.

Scott Kupor called him "one of like the most brilliant software developers around." He stayed in government work, helping redesign federal websites.

During the controversy over that efficiency drive, Kupor saw a government employee quoted as saying the government would never hire Ed. The reason was simple: he had no college degree and no five years of work experience.

That rule captured the hiring system Kupor had inherited. Almost every federal job description included a college degree requirement, which Kupor viewed as an imperfect proxy for skill.

Ed's lack of a degree, Kupor argued, had no bearing on his ability to write software. Yet under the old rules, he would either have been screened out or brought in at GS-5, the most entry-level rank.

That rank would have paid about $40,000 a year. Kupor said Ed would never have accepted it when he could earn about 10 times as much in Silicon Valley.

Kupor's answer was to place people according to proven ability. He said Ed should have been able to enter at GS-14 or GS-15, among the highest career ranks, because his work showed he could perform at that level.

The system, Kupor said, would not have allowed it. He is now pushing hiring based on tests and technical assessments, rather than diplomas and years served.

Questions people ask

What do GS-5 and GS-14 mean?

The General Schedule is the pay scale for most white-collar federal workers, with 15 grades. GS-5 is near the bottom for entry-level jobs requiring a degree, while GS-14 and GS-15 are senior expert and supervisory roles that often pay well above $100,000, depending on location.

What was the government efficiency team Ed joined?

It was a short-lived effort associated with Elon Musk to cut costs and overhaul federal operations, which brought in young engineers from the tech world. The push reduced the civilian workforce and started several modernization projects, including work on retirement processing and websites.

What does the Office of Personnel Management do?

The Office of Personnel Management acts as the federal government's human resources department. It sets hiring policy, pay rules, benefits, and performance standards for agencies across the civilian workforce.

More in Money