High-Return Funds Pitched as Low Risk Can Lock Up Your Money
Funds limit withdrawals to about 5% a month or quarter, a shock to savers used to selling anytime.

The Wall Street Skinny · Financial Times Reporter TELLS ALL: Sujeet Indap on Why Private Credit is Worse than Credit in 2008 | Caesars Part 3/3Kristen, a podcast host, and her husband needed cash to buy a house. They were invested in BREIT, Blackstone's giant real estate fund for individual investors.
Getting the money out was a major hassle, she said.
Her experience captures the wider test for private funds sold to ordinary savers as high return with low risk. The catch, hidden in the fine print, is that investors cannot always get their money back when they ask for it.
Sujeet Indap, the podcast guest, said the limit is deliberate. Many of these funds will release only about 5 percent of assets in a month or a quarter, so when many investors ask at once, the rest wait in line.
The push to sell such funds to retirement savers comes from necessity, Indap said. Allocations from pension funds, insurers, and sovereign wealth funds are mature and growing slowly, so firms looking to keep growing must tap the trillions of dollars in retirement savings.
That means loan funds known as business development companies, and their real estate cousins, are marketed through brokers and wealth managers to what Indap jokingly called doctors and dentists. The pitch emphasizes strong returns with little risk, with less attention to what happens if everyone wants cash together.
Indap pointed to the collapse of Silicon Valley Bank a few years ago as a warning about panics. Depositors asked for their money on a Friday, and the bank was gone by Sunday.
He said gates are meant to avoid that kind of rush in funds, where everyone asking at once would force the fund to sell good assets at fire sale prices and leave everyone worse off.
Retail investors are not used to being told no, he said. They can sell a stock, a mutual fund, or an exchange traded fund, and they can take money out of the bank. Learning that a private fund can refuse, for their own protection as well as the fund's, will require what he called socialization.
Kristen said the answer is blunter marketing before anyone invests. Buyers should have to confirm, more than once, that they know the money will stay locked up.
Questions people ask
What does it mean for a fund to be gated?
It means the manager has capped or paused withdrawals after too many investors ask for money at once. In many private real estate and credit funds, the gate is written into the rules, often around 5% of assets per month or quarter. Investors wait in line until the pressure eases.
What is BREIT?
BREIT is the Blackstone Real Estate Income Trust, a huge fund that owns warehouses, apartments, and other property and lets wealthy individuals invest. It became famous in late 2022 when heavy withdrawals triggered its gates. It has since met a large share of those backlogged requests.
Why would anyone accept a fund that locks up their money?
The trade is time for return. Because the manager does not have to sell buildings or loans in a panic to meet redemptions, the fund can hold longer term assets that often pay more. The risk is that you may need cash exactly when everyone else does.

