Harbor Cafe Voted Favorite Brunch With Friends
Harbor Cafe wins local fans with a polenta Benedict, acclaimed Bloody Marys, and a coffee slush topped with horchata whipped cream.

lookout.co · The 2026 Lookout List: Food & Drink Experiences - Lookout Santa CruzReaders voted Harbor Cafe in Santa Cruz their favorite for brunch with friends, praising its eggs Benedict lineup, poached eggs on an English muffin with hollandaise sauce, and a frozen coffee slush with alcohol topped with whipped cream flavored with horchata.
The cafe at 535 Seventh Ave. drew praise for what one brunch fan called "best selection of eggs Benedict," including the polenta Benedict.
That version uses polenta, a soft porridge made from cornmeal, in place of the usual base. Fans also call its Bloody Marys the best around.
One fan suggests the frozen spiked coffee slush, finished with whipped cream flavored with horchata, a sweet drink made with rice and cinnamon, calling it "oh, so good!"
It is a beloved brunch spot with staying power. Server Tate McGinty has worked there for three years, and some staff members have stayed for 10 years or more.
Questions people ask
What is eggs Benedict?
It is poached eggs and ham or Canadian bacon on a toasted English muffin, topped with hollandaise, a rich sauce made from egg yolks, butter, and lemon. Variations keep the eggs and sauce but swap the base or meat, which is why a polenta version stands out.
What is horchata?
In Mexico, it is usually a sweet, milky drink made from rice, cinnamon, vanilla, and sugar. It tastes creamy and lightly spiced, so whipped with cream it adds vanilla and cinnamon notes to iced coffee.


