Investor Says Defense Firms Need Big Civilian Sales to Work
Commercial scale pays for factories and workers that governments alone cannot support, investor Christian Garrett argues.

Sourcery with Molly O'Shea · SpaceX, Palantir, Anduril & Onodrim | The Return of ConglomeratesChristian Garrett, an investor, was explaining why he thinks the strongest military suppliers will not look like traditional defense contractors.
His argument came down to one line: “You’re going to need to be dominant in the commercial industry or else it just won’t work.”
By that, Garrett means a defense business should earn most of its money from civilian customers, not government contracts.
He points to Palantir, a data software company, and SpaceX, the rocket and satellite internet company, as the only examples. In the earnings periods he cited, he said, most of each company’s revenue came from commercial business.
That commercial scale, he argues, lets a company maintain factories, workers, and know-how that matter for defense, and then increase or reduce defense output as needed.
Government support alone, he argues, cannot pay for that much spare capacity. Markets, he adds, will value the diversification that comes with selling to both sides.
His other example is shipbuilding. He notes that about 68 percent of revenue at China’s defense primes comes from commercial work, and says China’s leading shipbuilder is so powerful because it dominates commercial manufacturing and also makes defense products.
Garrett distinguishes between two kinds of breadth. A small-c conglomerate sells many products in its own category, which expands its market, he says. A capital-C conglomerate goes further, selling across both commercial and government markets.
Only that second kind, he believes, can build the scale that modern defense needs, because the government is not “going to be able to subsidize” it alone.
Questions people ask
What does dual-use mean here?
Dual-use means a company, factory, or technology serves both civilian and military customers. A satellite internet network, a cargo shipyard, or data software can have everyday buyers and also be useful to a defense department.
Why would civilian sales make a defense supplier stronger?
A government-only supplier depends on a few large, irregular orders, so it can struggle to keep skilled staff and equipment ready between contracts. Steady commercial sales provide revenue, production volume, and practice, and defense output can then be raised or lowered when needed.
How does China fit into the shipbuilding example?
China has the world’s largest commercial shipbuilding industry by output, with state-linked yards building both cargo ships and naval vessels. That civilian volume supports shipyards, suppliers, and workers in a way military orders alone would not.



