KorvaJoin the waitlist
Tech

Look for Technology That Just Barely Works

Gmail creator Paul Buchheit says dismissal often means the timing is finally right.

AI image
Standard Capital · How Paul Buchheit Created Gmail

After Paul Buchheit, the Google engineer who created Gmail, finished explaining how he squeezed email into a web browser, talk turned to today's artificial intelligence tools that write software.

"Find the things that just barely work," Buchheit said. "That's the opportunity."

Buchheit argues that dismissal is often a timing signal. People who said a full program could not run in a browser were technically right, he said, just out of date.

By 2001 and 2002, he said, browsers had finally become just good enough. He repurposed a little used browser feature that let the browser contact a server without reloading the page, a trick he called a hack because programmers were using it in a way its designers had not intended.

That timing mattered because an earlier generation of startups had tried browser-only software and failed. Buchheit recalled a Google executive telling him a friend had tried it, that it did not work, and that he should not try it either.

Gmail was built about as early as it could have been, he said. The best browser available was Internet Explorer 6, Firefox was not yet out, and his team worked with early versions of Mozilla.

Some colleagues even feared Microsoft would break the JavaScript code Gmail depended on. Instead, Buchheit said, Microsoft issued one final update to Internet Explorer 6 that made it work better with Gmail.

He sees the same pattern in AI coding tools. What began as a joke about having a computer write all the code progressed to writing patches and finding bugs, until, in his account, the tools now write all the code.

Questions people ask

What is JavaScript, and why did people doubt it?

JavaScript is the programming language that runs inside web browsers and makes pages interactive. Buchheit says Gmail's JavaScript-heavy interface could crash browsers when pushed too hard. Earlier attempts at fully browser-based programs also were not very good, which is why many people doubted the approach.

How was Gmail different from older webmail?

Older webmail required reloading the whole page with every click. Gmail instead exchanged data with the server without reloading the whole page. For Buchheit, avoiding those full-page requests was an optimization driven by speed.

What does barely working mean for AI coding tools?

Buchheit says skeptics dismiss the tools because the code is sloppy. As with early browsers, he argues critics focus on the flaws while the capability keeps expanding from autocomplete to patches to writing all the code.

More in Tech